NL Appeal Court orders insurance to pay back premiums, lawyers for abuse survivors reviewing decision to determine next steps
A trial judge was right to void an insurance policy over the St. John’s Roman Catholic archdiocese’s failure to disclose sexual abuse allegations in the 1980s, but wrong to allow the insurance company to keep the premiums, Newfoundland and Labrador’s Court of Appeal has ruled.
In a decision released publicly on Wednesday, April 16, 2026, the court upheld a finding that the Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation of St. John’s breached its duty of good faith by not telling Guardian Insurance Company of Canada it was aware of the allegations against its clergy when it obtained a policy in 1980 and renewed it yearly for at least four years.
However, the court found there was no proof the archdiocese had intended to commit fraud, and ordered the insurance company to refund the…
View Cache