UNITED STATES
dotCommonweal
Grant Gallicho March 20, 2015
Today the Holy See announced that Cardinal Keith O’Brien of Scotland has resigned the “rights and privileges” of being a cardinal. The news follows the conclusion of a Vatican investigation of allegations that O’Brien sexually harrassed adult men, including a seminarian, and carried on a long-term sexual relationship with a priest. O’Brien, once an outspoken critic of homosexuality, resigned as archbishop of Edinburgh in 2013, admitting that “many times” his sexual conduct had “fallen below the standards expected of me as a priest, archbishop, and cardinal.” And he recused himself from the conclave that elected Pope Francis. Until now, O’Brien had been living in a seaside home apparantly enjoying the rights and privileges of a cardinal. Not anymore. He won’t be able to participate in any more conclaves, or act as an adviser to the pope. Still, O’Brien gets to keep his title, even if he’s permitted to wear his red hat and vestments only in private.
This is “an extraordinarily decisive act of governance that combines justice with mercy,” according to Gerard O’Collins. Andrea Tornielli called the pope’s decision “courageous.” It may be merciful and it’s certainly extraordinary (the last time a cardinal resigned was in 1927). But is it decisive? Courageous? I have my doubts.
First, the allegations against O’Brien surfaced nearly two years ago. Pope Francis did not appoint Archbishop Charles Scicluna–once the Vatican’s top abuse investigator–to look into the situation until 2014, well after the pope had ordered O’Brien to get out of Scotland for a few months. Of course, thorough investigations take time, and Scicluna is a busy man, but it’s not as though O’Brien’s accusers were unknown, or difficult to reach. They sent their initial complaints to the papal nuncio in late 2012 and early 2013. Why has it taken nearly two years to get to the bottom of this?
Note: This is an Abuse Tracker excerpt. Click the title to view the full text of the original article. If the original article is no longer available, see our News Archive.