Abuse Case Lawsuit Tied to City Parish Filed

Observer Today
September 9, 2019

https://www.observertoday.com/news/local-region/2019/09/abuse-case-lawsuit-tied-to-city-parish-filed/

In a Child Victims Act lawsuit filed Monday in state Supreme Court in Erie County, the plaintiff, referred to as PB-5 Doe, has filed a civil suit agianst the Diocese of Buffalo, Holy Trinity Roman Catholic Church and Holy Trinity School. The lawsuit claims Monsignor Valerio Bernardo, then a pastor at the church, allegedly began abusing the girl when she was 5 and continued to abuse her for several years. The plaintiff, now 60, lives in Springville, N.Y., and was a student at the school in the 1960s during a time when she and her family were parishioners at Holy Trinity Church.

Bernardo became the seventh pastor in Holy Trinity Roman Catholic Church’s history in July 1945 and remained at the church until February 1974, according to the church’s website. Bernardo was the driving force behind purchasing land on Central Avenue in Dunkirk for a school and convent in the 1960s with a new church and rectory built on the site in the early 1970s.

The lawsuit states Bernardo was the priest of Holy Trinity Church and was also involved with Holy Trinity School with duties that included mentoring, disciplining and counseling children. Those duties allowed the priest to be alone with children and to have unfettered and unsupervised access to them. The church allowed priests to have physical contact with minors in a manner consistent with providing discipline, counseling, educational and spiritual guidance and leadership and the church required students, like plaintiff, to accept discipline and instruction from clergy, including Msgr. Bernardo, and to obey their orders.

“Beginning in or about 1964, when plaintiff was 5 years old, Msgr. Bernardo routinely took plaintiff out of her classroom at defendant Holy Trinity School and brought her into a bathroom and to another area on school or church premises where he could be alone with her,” the lawsuit states. “At the aforementioned time and place, Msgr. Bernardo engaged in unpermitted, forcible and harmful sexual contact with plaintiff. This sexual abuse, which was a regular and repeat occurrence until approximately 1968-1969, occurred on the premises of defendants Holy Trinity Church and Holy Trinity School. Plaintiff’s relationship to defendants as a vulnerable child and student, and the culture of the Catholic Church which defendants endorsed, put pressure on plaintiff not to report the sexual molestation and abuse.”

The lawsuit alleges church officials either knew or should have known that Bernardo was a danger to children, stating that the church should have known of acts of child sexual abuse by Bernardo of other children.