July 23, 2005

Judge wonít release ex-priestís records

ILLINOIS
Daily Herald

By Tona Kunz
Daily Herald Staff Writer
Posted Saturday, July 23, 2005

The mental health records of a former Geneva priest wonít become leverage in a civil suit against him for sexual abuse.

An attorney for the two women suing Mark Campobello and the Roman Catholic Diocese of Rockford had sought the medical records. The women hope to find references to evaluations and treatment referrals related to the sexual abuse, which would show what the diocese knew about the abuse and when.

Although Kane County Judge F. Keith Brown found the diocese had records of treatment referrals made after the diocese became concerned with Campobelloís conduct, the judge deemed the records unusable in civil lawsuits. The conduct of concern was not identified.

Brown ruled that all of the records he was provided by the diocese were either irrelevant to the civil suits or protected by the stateís health confidentiality act.

Key to the confidentiality protection is the fact that Campobello has objected to the release of the documents. The diocese, which acted as a go-between for Campobello and the medical providers, does not have the right, nor can it be forced, to turn over the records over Campobelloís objections, Brown ruled.

Posted by kshaw at July 23, 2005 07:28 AM