Manchester
NH Resources – November 2002
Note: The documents in this file are offered solely
for educational purposes. Should any reader wish to quote or reproduce these
documents for sale, the original publisher should be contacted and permission
requested. BishopAccountability.org makes no claim regarding the accuracy
of any document we post.
Alleged abuse victim meets with church task force
By Kathryn Marchocki
Manchester (NH) Union Leader
November 2, 2002
Paul Ciaramitaro gets upset when he sees Manchester Bishop John B. McCormack
smile on television.
Ciaramitaro doesn't smile much.
The 31-year-old Gloucester, Mass., man said he struggles with depression,
loneliness, inability to trust and post-traumatic stress disorder.
All, he said, are the result of having been molested by a Catholic priest
whom McCormack knew was abusing children, yet allowed to remain in ministry
and even be promoted to pastor of St. Ann Church in Gloucester in 1985.
Ciaramitaro said the Rev. Joseph E. Birmingham molested him at least a
dozen times as a teenager in 1985 and 1986 when Ciaramitaro worked part-time
at St. Ann rectory.
Now he wants an apology from McCormack, who was Cardinal Bernard F. Law's
secretary for ministerial personnel when Birmingham was promoted pastor
despite numerous warnings from parents as far back as the 1960s that Birmingham
had been abusing children at other parishes.
"I'm asking for a public apology," Ciaramitaro said yesterday
after the Manchester Diocesan Task Force on Sexual Misconduct Policy met
in Manchester.
"McCormack had a lot to do with this. Where is his accountability?
He did not do his job," he said.
Ciaramitaro is one of about 55 people who claimed in a lawsuit that Birmingham,
who died in 1989, sexually abused them while he served at various Massachusetts
parishes.
He also belongs to the Survivors of Joseph Birmingham, a group of Birmingham's
alleged victims.
Cardinal Law met with 70 to 100 members of the group at a Dracut, Mass.,
parish Tuesday and apologized to them for the hurt they suffered.
Robert Morton of Newport, who is a member of the group but not an abuse
victim, said the Survivors of Joseph Birmingham asked for a similar meeting
with McCormack in the spring.
"We got stonewalled," Morton said.
Ciaramitaro encouraged the task force in their work.
"I like what you're doing. It sounds like you're trying," he
said. "It's a start."
"So much has been taken from me and we can prevent that from happening,"
he added.
Morton asked the task force if a representative from a victim's group
could sit on the task force.
Peter Flood, who represents the lay group Voice of the Faithful in New
Hampshire, also requested his group have a seat on the task force.
"I think one of the people from Voice of the Faithful would be helpful,"
Flood said.
Task force chairman Donna P. Sytek said this would have to be approved
by the bishop.
Priest leaves Jaffrey after admitting affair
By Associated Press
Nashua (NH) Telegraph
November 3, 2002
http://www.nashuatelegraph.com/main.asp?ArticleID=67091&SectionID=25&SubSectionID=354&S=1
Jaffrey -- The Catholic priest who recently admitted he had a homosexual
affair with a teenager is leaving St. Patrick Church, which was plunged
into turmoil by the admission.
The Rev. Roland Cote, who worked at Nashua’s St. Louis de Gonzague
Church until June, told parishioners he will leave today. Parish secretary
Liz DiRusso said Cote is expected to say weekend Masses.
Cote admitted to parishioners in September he had a long-term affair
with a teenage boy in the 1980s. Authorities investigated him in April
after the teenager, who is now 35, told authorities the priest sexually
abused him as a minor in the 1980s.
Prosecutors said they could not bring charges because the teenager was
older than 16 when he first met Cote.
Bishop John McCormack transferred Cote to Jaffrey in June without informing
parishioners in his new parish about his past.
Parishioners told The Union Leader they weren’t told where Cote
is going, or who will replace him.
The Rev. Edward Arsenault, chancellor of the Catholic Diocese of Manchester
and delegate for sexual misconduct, would not comment.
“There is a relationship between a pastor and his parish,”
Arsenault said.
Diocesan officials claimed the teenager told them he was 18 when the
affair began. The diocese’s sexual misconduct policy defines a minor
as someone younger than 18.
Prosecutors said the teenager was at least 16½ years old when
he first met Cote, but they could never determine his exact age.
Cote’s transfer to St. Patrick last summer followed the controversial
departure of the previous pastor, the Rev. James “Seamus”
MacCormack.
Two months after resigning from the parish, MacCormack filed a lawsuit
accusing the bishop and other church officials of waging a campaign to
keep him silent about a pornography collection discovered in the residence
of a Manchester priest who died in 1999. The diocese denied the allegation.
Bishop replaces pastor, apologizes
By Associated Press
Nashua (NH) Telegraph
November 4, 2002
http://www.nashuatelegraph.com/main.asp?ArticleID=67172&SectionID=25&SubSectionID=354
Manchester -- Bishop has apologized for the problems faced by parishioners
of a church whose priest had a sexual relationship with a teenage boy,
and has named an interim replacement priest.
“I am sorry for the pain, confusion and division that has resulted
from this series of events at St. Patrick Parish in Jaffrey,” McCormack
said in a statement Sunday.
McCormack, bishop of the Diocese of Manchester, transferred the Rev.
Roland Cote to Jaffrey in June from Nashua’s St. Louis de Gonzague
parish, without informing parishioners in his new parish about his past.
Cote admitted to parishioners in September he had a long-term affair
with a teenage boy in the 1980s. Authorities investigated him in April
after the teenager, now 35, told authorities the priest sexually abused
him as a minor in the 1980s.
Prosecutors said they could not bring charges because the boy was over
16 when he first met Cote.
McCormack wrote a letter earlier to parishioners telling them that though
Cote’s actions were wrong, they did not violate the Diocese of Manchester’s
policies on child sex abuse.
He also said he was confident Cote “had not engaged in sexual misconduct
with a minor and that he is not a risk to children or young people.”
“I am confident that I made the right decision even though it was
made at the expense of your knowing about his entire personal background,”
McCormack said.Cote told parishioners Friday he was resigning immediately
as their priest.
“During the past months, the divisions within the parish have become
worse and this reality has been emotionally and physically draining to
parishioners as well as me,” he said Sunday in a statement. He said
he needed time to rest and “to put things back together.”
In his statement, McCormack said he has accepted the resignation and
granted Cote a leave of absence for medical reasons.
He said he has appointed the Rev. William Quirk, a retired priest, as
administrator of St. Patrick Parish until he can appoint a new pastor.
“To those who disagree with my decisions and remain upset, it is
my intention and hope that the steps we take in the months ahead will
help you regain confidence in your parish community and in me,”
he said.
He also said that upon the recommendation of a Diocesan Review Board,
he had asked Cote to participate in an evaluation “to assure me
. . . of his ability to fulfill his resolve to live a chaste and celibate
life as a priest.”
He said Cote “willingly participated in this evaluation, which
has confirmed that he is resolved to live a chaste and celibate life and
that he is not a risk to minors.”
Task force gets earful about abuse policy
By Albert McKeon
Nashua (NH) Telegraph
November 9, 2002
http://www.nashuatelegraph.com/main.asp?Search=1&ArticleID=67508&SectionID=25&SubSectionID=354&S=1
Manchester -- In full listening mode, they heard calls for true church
reform, including repeated demands for the resignation of Bishop John
McCormack.
A task force reviewing the Diocese of Manchester’s sexual misconduct
policy held the second of four “listening sessions” Friday
afternoon. The sessions provide Catholics and others a chance to offer
input on the policy and matters relating to the clergy abuse scandal.
About 50 people crowded into a St. Pius X Church hall, and many of those
who spoke questioned how effective the task force would be considering
it reports directly to McCormack. Many sought a review board independent
of a bishop who they consider highly culpable for the past shielding of
abusive priests.
“You have a daunting task,” Manchester resident Lorraine
Lamontagne said to the 12-member task force. “I’m skeptical
of your authority in the matter. I have no faith in the bishop. He’s
a detriment to the diocese and to the recovery of everyone.”
Lamontagne furthered her criticism by asking the diocese to sell its
elaborate Manchester home for the bishop and have him “join the
real world.” She also questioned McCormack’s recent handling
of a former Nashua priest’s admission that he had a relationship
with a teenager.
Many expressed skepticism that the task force could fulfill its goal
to evaluate and strengthen the policy, while others vented anger toward
McCormack’s handling of abusive priests when he worked for the Archdiocese
of Boston. No one spoke in defense of the church or its policy.
Nancy Rollins – director of the state Division for Children, Youth
and Families – said the diocese ignored policy guidelines she had
suggested. The current policy does not require a report to legal authorities
if an abuser is unknown, but state law requires the reporting of all suspected
abuse cases, Rollins said.
Further, the diocese lists the reporting of abuse as fourth on its procedural
list for complaint investigations, but this should rank first, Rollins
said.
She also criticized the policy’s guideline for the diocese to meet
with an alleged victim and accused perpetrator prior to determining if
the case adheres to reporting requirements. This compromises any investigation,
she said.The session started with a college professor demanding wholesale
changes on how the church conducts itself.
“The task force must courageously carry through with its recommendations,”
said James Farrell, an associate professor of communications at the University
of New Hampshire. “Will you have the courage to find the truth .
. . or will you merely do the bishop’s errand?”
Farrell, a self-described devout Catholic, pointed to how the term “child”
does not appear in the policy, but he said McCormack has made numerous
comments this year about protecting children. He asked for the diocese
to fully disclose its abuse files, information on financial settlements
and details on all other past matters that he essentially deemed unsavory.
Farrell and a few other speakers mentioned their displeasure with McCormack’s
handling of the Rev. Roland Cote, who until this year was pastor of St.
Louis de Gonzague Church in Nashua. Cote this year told the diocese about
a past relationship with a teenager who the diocese claims was of consenting
age at the time, and shortly thereafter the priest was transferred to
St. Patrick Church in Jaffrey.
When parishioners there pressed Cote on the relationship, he denied it.
But McCormack admitted to the relationship during a civil deposition involving
his handling of Boston priests, so Cote soon apologized to his new parish.
Outraged St. Patrick parishioners chided McCormack for the transfer,
and Cote has since resigned.
Ellen Hayward of Manchester asked that the Jaffrey parish have a say
in finding its new pastor, including oversight on interviews and a candidate’s
records. Farrell said McCormack’s handling of Cote shows the “bishop
will disregard policy if it is in his interests to do so.”
Farrell added: “If Cote can resign, then it is true times 10, true
times 100” for McCormack.
Scott Maurer of Goffstown questioned why the diocese needs a lengthy
sexual abuse policy or the work of a task force. “It’s very
simple. If a crime has been committed, simply report it to police –
end of story,” he said.
The task force consists mostly of laypeople, with one priest and one
nun. Members include former New Hampshire House Speaker Donna Sytek, BAE
Systems executive Richard Ashooh, Bishop Guertin teacher Robert Goyette
and his wife, Susan Goyette, a medical transcriptionist at St. Joseph
Family Medical Center.
Sytek said the committee will report to the bishop by Christmas with
policy suggestions. But Farrell said any changes “will amount to
little more than rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic” if McCormack
is in charge of implementing them.
Bishop must resign, abuse policy panel told
By Kathryn Marchocki
Manchester (NH) Union Leader
November 9, 2002
Several Catholics yesterday told the task force reviewing the Manchester
Diocese's sexual abuse policy that Bishop John B. McCormack must resign
before the panel's work can restore trust in the church.
Any new policy "will be viewed as little more than a hollow sham
if it must rest its authority on the credibility of a bishop who, while
in Boston, violated law, morality and common sense in protecting pedophile
priests," James Farrell said at the task force's second "listening
session," held in Manchester.
McCormack's alleged mishandling of child sexual abuse by clergy in the
Boston Archdiocese and recent cases of priestly misconduct here prove
he is a crippled moral leader, said Farrell, who in the spring wrote a
letter calling for McCormack's resignation.
A new policy also must hold accountable any bishop or church administrator
who protects predatory priests or conspires to hide the abuse, Farrell
said.
These bishops should face dismissal from ministry just as an offending
priest does, he added.
The current policy does not hold church hierarchy accountable.
State Division for Children, Youth and Families Director Nancy Rollins
said the policy must make compliance with mandatory reporting requirements
of suspected child abuse to civil authorities its foremost and immediate
priority.
It should be the first step in investigating any complaint and not the
fourth, where it is found in the current policy, Rollins said.
She also recommended that it not be diocesan practice to hold initial
meetings with the alleged victim and the accused clergy before deciding
whether to contact state and local authorities as required by law.
"This could compromise an investigation into child abuse," Rollins
said.
The diocese also should immediately place an alleged abuser on administrative
leave while law enforcement and child protection workers investigate a
complaint, she said.
Rollins said she contacted the diocese earlier this year, offering to
help develop a new policy.
"I must say that none of our recommendations were actually entered
into this document," she said.
Brad Bauer, a Bedford resident and investigator with the Merrimack County
Attorney's Office, said the diocese must make reporting suspected child
abuse to civil authorities a priority.
"I've been involved in some investigations involving victims of priests.
It's interesting to me that I never once received a report from church
authorities, even when they (victims) said they made reports," Bauer
said.
Bauer also called on the diocese to turn over all records of abuse complaints
to civil authorities "so we can help substantiate the cases."
While the "listening session" was intended to get public comment
on policy changes, several who spoke openly doubted whether the group
could effect real change because members were appointed by the bishop
and their recommendations must meet his final approval.
They also criticized the 12-member task force for not having an abuse
victim represented on it.
"I, like many others, are very skeptical of your authority in this
matter. I don't have any faith in Bishop McCormack," said Lorraine
Lamontagne, a former Manchester school board member.
"I would like see Bishop McCormack leave and take his cronies with
him," Lamontagne said in front of the 40 to 50 people who attended
the session at St. Pius X Parish Center. She said the bishop should sell
his North River Road residence and move to a rectory.
"I think it's about time these guys who are in these palaces join
the real world," she said.
David Meltzer of Pelham, who converted to Catholicism when he was 18,
said he was dismayed to hear of several religious sisters and priests
dismissing abuse victims as simply trying to make money.
Meltzer said he was molested as a child for five years by the elevator
operator in his New York City apartment building.
"My father was an alcoholic. He (the abuser) threatened that if I
ever spoke of it, he would take my father's head and bang it up against
a wall and take him to the top of the stairs and let him roll down. He
had me totally in his control," he said.
Meltzer said he buried these memories until about eight years ago, when
two of his former students told him they had been molested.
Then memories of his own abuse burst forth.
"I wish people knew and believed that it could really be true, that
you could not remember, then remember years later," he said.
Meltzer said there shouldn't be a statute of limitations for reporting
sexual abuse.
Bishop expects new policy will help
By Albert McKeon
Nashua (NH) Telegraph
November 14, 2002
http://www.nashuatelegraph.com/main.asp?ArticleID=67798&SectionID=25&SubSectionID=354&S=21
Bishop John McCormack has expressed confidence that a revised sexual
abuse policy for the American-based Catholic Church will protect children
while guaranteeing due process to accused priests.
“Dallas was a first step; this was a second step,” McCormack
said Wednesday in a telephone interview from Washington, D.C., where the
U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops is holding its semiannual meeting.
The USCCB met last summer in Dallas, where it produced a charter that
allowed bishops to remove from the ministry any priest who faces a credible
charge of abuse. The Vatican blanched at some aspects of the policy –
specifically that it did not follow universal church mandates that protect
the rights of clergy.
A joint Vatican-USCCB committee then recommended revisions that the bishops
think will allow the policy to maintain the mandate of Dallas while balancing
concerns from Rome. The bishops adopted those revisions Wednesday, and
now expect the Vatican to approve the finalized policy, making the document
binding.
“It retains the heart of the (Dallas) charter and (Vatican) norms.
It remains intact to assure the protection of children and assistance
to children,” McCormack said.
As the bishops gathered in Washington this week, critics denounced the
revisions. They felt the revisions, once approved, would weaken the Dallas
policy and put them back at square one.
McCormack said the revised policy still lets bishops remove guilty priests
from public ministry, while ensuring that clergy can protect its rights
through “a fair and unbiased process.”
“The bishop has to be fair and just,” McCormack said. “If
he wants to impose a penalty on a priest, or if the priest wants to defend
his innocence, the bishop should offer a fair process. In our civil law,
we do the same thing. The church has the same thing.”
That process entitles a priest to a clerical tribunal at the Vatican.
Critics labeled the tribunal as a secretive process that will keep priests
in the ministry and place a greater burden on victims.
McCormack maintained that even if a tribunal exonerates a priest, a bishop
and his policy review board could still remove the cleric from ministry
if there’s creditable evidence he has committed an act of abuse.
“The bishop is free not to assign that man” to any ministry,
McCormack said. “The bishop is ultimately responsible.”
Further, a bishop can ask Rome to waive on an individual basis the church’s
statute of limitations on the reporting of abuse, he said. Victims must
file a complaint by the time they reach age 28, but an American bishop
can extend that with the waiver.
The bishops will still report all abuse cases to civil authorities, even
though the policy requires only following local civil laws, McCormack
said. What the charter allows – in a departure from past church
norms – is the reporting of abuse to authorities when the alleged
victim has reached adulthood, he said.
“Now you can bring a priest to trial, or a priest can seek a trial,
whereas before it just depended on the administrative act of the bishop,
which was not complete,” he said.
The bishops did not rush a policy in Dallas – they had concern
for the rights of priests then – but they did not know what specific
steps to take, McCormack said. The joint committee applied church norms
to the policy and essentially clarified the bishops’ wishes to protect
priests, he said.
McCormack said he realizes that Catholics and others in New Hampshire
are skeptical of a task force he appointed to review the Diocese of Manchester’s
abuse policy and its adherence to the USCCB charter and the law.
The 12 members of the task force – comprising lay people and a
priest and nun – have “personal integrity” and they
will make the necessary recommendations, regardless of who appointed them,
McCormack said.
“Then it’s up to me,” McCormack said. “It’s
a pretty public task, and that’s why we’re doing it, to help
those concerned and skeptical. We’re trying to do what’s best
for the victims, children and priests.”
The policy will succeed, but as the church works to protect children
and make sure future candidates for the priesthood are screened more carefully,
there “needs to be much more healing,” he said.
“We’re remembering people want to come to the church and
feel it’s a safe environment. Victims want to be healed, and our
priests who work so hard want to have that trust restored so they can
be relied upon. There were only a few among us who broke that trust.”
McCormack backs revised church policy
By Kathryn Marchocki
Manchester (NH) Union Leader
November 14, 2002
The revised child sexual abuse policy approved yesterday by the nation's
Catholic bishops would enable them to permanently resolve cases of predatory
clerics through church trials, Manchester Bishop John B. McCormack said.
The policy also would require diocesan bishops to ask the Vatican to lift
the canonical statute of limitations in each case of clergy sexual abuse,
he added.
Canon law says alleged victims must report abuse by age 28.
McCormack, who voted with the majority of the nation's bishops when they
adopted the revised charter 246-7, said the document provided a clearer
and fairer way of dealing with abusive clerics than that adopted by bishops
in Dallas in June.
"It strengthened it. It clarified it. It specified the procedures
to be used," the bishop said by telephone from Washington.
The revised policy and norms must get final Vatican approval before they
would become mandatory in all Catholic dioceses in the U.S.
McCormack said he expects a Vatican response by year's end.
"The substance of what we passed in Dallas remains intact. We have
kept our focus on protecting children, responding to victims and involving
lay review boards. I join my fellow bishops in strongly endorsing our
actions today," McCormack said.
The current Manchester diocesan sexual misconduct policy relies on an
administrative decision by the bishop to remove from active ministry any
cleric facing a single credible allegation of child sexual abuse, no matter
when it occurred.
Under the revised norms approved yesterday, bishops would report an abuse
allegation to the Holy See and seek an exemption from the canonical statute
of limitations, McCormack said.
"My sense is that Rome has agreed to lift it in each case that we
ask for it," McCormack said.
A church trial then would be held, either at the Vatican or before a local
tribunal, he added.
A trial would address penalties for offending priests and result in a
final resolution to a cleric's canonical status while protecting his due
process rights, McCormack said.
"What it provides for is an unbiased procedure and a lifting of the
statute of limitations," McCormack explained.
Even if a church trial finds an accused priest innocent, the local bishop
still would have administrative authority to remove him from ministry
if he believes the allegation to be credible, diocesan spokesman Patrick
McGee said.
Other than the addition of church trials, McCormack said the proposed
policy and norms largely conform to the Manchester diocese's existing
sexual misconduct policy.
A diocesan task force reviewing the current diocesan sexual misconduct
policy is waiting for Vatican approval of the new norms before it can
make its final recommendations to the bishop for changes to the local
policy.
These recommendations can strengthen the existing policy, but cannot be
in conflict with the canon law or the new norms.
The revised norms also would require each diocese to comply with "all
applicable civil laws with respect to the reporting of allegations of
sexual abuse of minors."
McCormack said the Manchester diocese has "always reported sexual
misconduct with a minor" and has cooperated with civil authorities
whenever a case was reported.
Grand jury eyes role of NH diocese in sex abuse
By J.M. Hirsch, Associated Press
Manchester (NH) Union Leader
November 17, 2002
Concord -- An investigative grand jury is hearing evidence about whether
the state's Roman Catholic hierarchy covered up sexual abuse by priests,
a sign of the seriousness and scope of the state's investigation.
James Higgins, a lawyer for the diocese, confirmed the existence of the
grand jury in a motion filed last month in Manchester.
"The grand jury is currently meeting in Hillsborough County and has
interviewed certain individuals in connection with the attorney general's
probe," Higgins said.
Attorney General Philip McLaughlin would not comment, noting that grand
jury proceedings are secret.
The grand jury could issue an indictment, or formal charge, or could do
nothing. The investigation is expected to end next month.
The Rev. Edward Arsenault, chancellor of the Diocese of Manchester and
delegate for sexual misconduct, did not immediately return a call seeking
comment.
Since February, McLaughlin's office has been investigating whether diocesan
officials violated child endangerment laws by transferring from parish
to parish priests suspected of molesting children.
Higgins' Oct. 1 motion was in a civil lawsuit with no direct bearing on
the state's investigation. In an affidavit in the same case, David Vicinanzo,
another lawyer for the diocese, said the grand jury was "examining
the activity of the diocese and its administrators over the period of
the last 40 years."
Grand juries are panels of citizens who hear evidence in secret from prosecutors
and witnesses, usually to issue indictments.
There is no formal difference between an investigative grand jury and
a traditional grand jury. Both have the power to subpoena witnesses and
records and issue indictments, a process that can take as little as one
or two days.
However, in an investigative grand jury, prosecutors may call witnesses
beyond those needed for an indictment.
Witnesses called before the investigative panel would be required to testify
or face contempt charges. The only exception would be if a privilege applied,
such as the right against self-incrimination.
McLaughlin has said the investigation stretches back to the 1960s and
involves nearly 50 priests. He has been quoted as saying he was "absolutely
convinced" church leaders had broken the law by knowingly reassigning
abusive priests.
Last month, however, McLaughlin told The Union Leader that he was not
speaking about New Hampshire church officials when he made those comments
in June to The New Hampshire Sunday News. He said he was making a generic
response "with respect to what I thought was a matter of public safety
given the U.S. bishops' failure to address their responsibility to protect
children from abusive priests in the sexual abuse charter they adopted
in Dallas in June.
Authorities have said they are investigating the church in New Hampshire
as an institution, but have not ruled out charging individuals.
One focus is whether any offenses occurred too long ago to prosecute under
the endangerment law, and if not, if there is enough evidence to bring
charges. The law has a one-year statute of limitations.
Former prosecutor John Kissinger said the use of the grand jury indicates
authorities are preparing to move forward, possibly but not necessarily
with charges.
"It obviously suggests that the matter is being taken with a high
degree of seriousness by the Attorney General's Office and suggests that
they are trying to advance the investigation," Kissinger said.
On the other hand, he said, it's not uncommon for investigative grand
juries to conclude there is not enough evidence to bring charges.
Kissinger said investigative grand juries also are good ways for prosecutors
to give a case a test run, as well as to commit witnesses to testimony.
Violations of the endangerment law are misdemeanors punishable by a year
in jail for individuals and fines of up to $20,000 for organizations.
Both can be prosecuted for willfully violating their duty to care for,
protect and support children.
Bishop John B. McCormack has headed the diocese since 1998. Before then,
he was a top aide to Cardinal Bernard Law dealing with sexual misconduct
by priests in Massachusetts.
McCormack has been criticized here and in Boston for minimizing or dismissing
sexual misconduct allegations against priests.
Skeptics have doubt about church task force
By Associated Press
Nashua (NH) Telegraph
November 18, 2002
http://www.nashuatelegraph.com/main.asp?ArticleID=68051&SectionID=25&SubSectionID=354&S=21
Concord, N.H. -- Critics of a task force set up to examine Roman Catholic
Church policies regarding priests accused of sexually abusing children
wonder if the group will be effective.
At the same time, the task force says it is determined to strengthen
the rules aimed at preventing such abuse.
Jeff Blanchard of Concord says there is a sense of openness when the
task force has met with residents at several recent “listening sessions.”
But he wonders whether the Diocese of Manchester will heed the advice
the group gives it.
“In the laity, there tends to be a skepticism, a trust that is
broken,” Blanchard said.
Others say the church needs to change its culture as well as its policies.
“I think we need to educate, educate, educate,” said Sister
Maureen Sullivan, a theologian at Saint Anselm College.
The Rev. Edward Arsenault of the Diocese of Manchester said the church
is committed to responding to the public’s concerns in a way that
is open and clear.
Manchester Bishop John McCormack last month convened the task force,
chaired by former House Speaker Donna Sytek, to evaluate the diocese’s
sexual misconduct policy.
The group has since held “listening sessions” with residents
throughout the state.
Some residents who have attended the meetings have called for McCormack’s
resignation in light of revelations that some priests accused of abuse
years ago were shuttled from parish to parish. Others have asked that
the church be more open.
Sytek said she has made sure to pass along all of the comments to McCormack’s
office.
“It would be unsatisfactory to me to go out and hear all this other
stuff and not do anything with it,” she said. “People are
hurting.”
Church trying to openly address sexuality
By Associated Press
Nashua (NH) Telegraph
November 18, 2002
http://www.nashuatelegraph.com/main.asp?ArticleID=68052&SectionID=25&SubSectionID=354&S=21
Manchester -- Bishop John McCormack says men who are gay should not necessarily
be precluded from becoming priests.
He told The New Hampshire Sunday news in a story published Sunday that
what is most important is that a priest commit himself to a life of celibacy
and follow church doctrine.
At the same time, he conceded there are obstacles for gay men who want
to join the priesthood. McCormack said he doesn’t think the Roman
Catholic Church has ever accepted a man who it knew was living an openly
gay lifestyle.
McCormack said the church is looking for priests who are mature and of
high integrity.
The comments come as the church reevaluates its policies for handling
sexual abuse allegations against priests.
“In terms of orientation or same-sex attraction, I think it would
really depend on how the person has controlled this or lived this in their
life,” McCormack said.
McCormack said he doesn’t believe the sexual orientation of priests
accused of abuse is necessarily to blame for their alleged actions. He
said the issue is more complicated.
“I think pedophilia is one issue,” McCormack said. “I
think men who abused post-pubescent boys is another issue. And I think
living one’s life with integrity, be you heterosexual or homosexual,
is another issue.”
While some observers have said that the Roman Catholic Church has not
done a good job of openly addressing issues of sexuality, McCormack said
clergy are making great strides in that area.
“In the seminary, at one time it was assumed everybody was heterosexual,”
he said. “And now they say, ‘Wait a second, we really have
to address the man who has concerns about same-sex attraction.’
So I think that’s dealt with much more forthrightly today in the
seminary.”
Victim of sex abuse by Rev. Talbot talks of guilt, fear, pain
By Kathryn Marchocki
Manchester (NH) Union Leader
November 18, 2002
Former Keene resident Dennis Horion told no one about the sordid car
trips he said the Rev. Francis A. Talbot took him on as a child.
Horion said Talbot routinely picked him up at his grandmother's Manchester
house in his sleek sedan to get ice cream, go bowling or visit relatives.
Horion said all were innocent pursuits -- and all tainted when Talbot
reached across the front seat and put his hand inside Horion's pants.
"I felt the same way every time he did it. 'What do you want down
there?' My parents don't even do that," Horion, 50, recounted.
"I knew nothing of sex. When I saw my picture, I was shocked at how
fresh faced I was at that age. I had no chance against this guy,"
added Horion, who said Talbot abused him from approximately 1959 to 1964
when he was about 7 to 12 years old.
Talbot, now 66, is Horion's second cousin, the family priest whose first
name Horion took for confirmation.
But he was even more than that, Horion explained, describing the exalted
status a cleric held in the strict French Catholic world in which he was
raised.
"God was a priest. And a priest was God," explained Horion,
whose family lived in Hooksett before moving to Keene. Horion has been
living in Atlanta, Ga., for the past 17 years.
"If a priest was untoward toward you, you would have to defend yourself
against God as a 7-year-old," he added.
Horion told no one about the alleged abuses until he was 19, when he said
he confided in his older sister.
"If I told my dad, he would have shot Francis Talbot. That is the
entire reason I kept quiet -- I didn't want to lose a father and a mentor,"
said Horion, who is self-employed as a custom designer of men's clothes.
Horion said the alleged abuse escalated to attempted anal rape during
a sleepover at Talbot's mother's house in Manchester when he was about
11 years old.
Horion said Talbot came into his bedroom during the night and sat down
beside him. He said he smelled alcohol on Talbot's breath.
"I'm cold. . .Can I come in and get warm with you?" Horion recounted
Talbot asking.
"What do you say to a priest?" Horion asked. "I didn't
have any concept of what he was doing. He rolled me over. . .laid down
on top of me and tried to rape me."
Horion said his cries and screams frightened Talbot, who left the room
angry.
Horion said he was in about eighth grade when Talbot took him fishing
at Lake Massabesic and allegedly molested him for the last time. Talbot
was more aggressive than ever before, "essentially attacking me,"
Horion said, adding he fought the priest off.
"I told him I want to go home. I think he figured out he had popped
the edge of the envelope. He knew he was right on the verge of me telling
my father," Horion said.
Horion said he didn't see his second cousin again until his junior year
at St. Anselm College in the early 1970s. Horion took a part-time job
at the state's youth detention facility in Manchester, known then as the
New Hampshire Industrial School, when he ran into Talbot, who worked there
as a part-time chaplain from 1968 to 1988.
Horion, who said by then he had become a "wild buck" who had
difficulty fitting in with his family and meeting their expectations,
locked eyes with Talbot in an angry stare.
"When he saw me, he ran like a rabbit," Horion said.
Horion said his sin was not speaking up then.
"That would have been the brave thing. What I'm doing now is attempting
to reconcile my culpability," Horion said of his decision to break
with the anonymity offered him as one of 65 men and women who joined a
potential class action suit filed against the Manchester diocese.
Had he had the courage and strength of character to do something at that
time, Horion believes he could have prevented Talbot from allegedly abusing
a Manchester youth from about 1989 to 1996.
Cody Goodwin, 22, claims in a civil suit that Talbot sexually assaulted
him from the age of 9 until he turned 16 and was strong enough to fight
the cleric off.
Goodwin alleges Talbot abused him virtually every Monday when Goodwin
worked at the priest's home in Manchester.
"I just don't want to talk to anybody right now," Talbot said
recently when reached at his Manchester home by telephone.
"I am so broken hearted about all of this," he added.
Talbot, who was ordained in the early 1960s, was on the list of 14 priests
accused of past sexual misconduct with children released by Manchester
Bishop John B. McCormack last February. His ministry was suspended in
2000 when the diocese received a child sexual abuse allegation against
him, church officials have said.
The priest has been accused in two civil suits filed this year of abusing
an unidentified Concord man and Robert Plourde of Manchester. Both men
claim Talbot molested them at the former New Hampshire Industrial School
in the 1960s.
Another of Talbot's alleged victims was part of a nearly $1 million settlement
the Manchester diocese reached with 16 people last month. McCormack mailed
letters of apology to the alleged victims involved in that settlement.
Talbot also served as Catholic chaplain at the New Hampshire State Prison
in Concord. The prison's 1976-78 biennial report said he was chaplain
there for the previous 10 years.
He was stationed at St. Patrick Parish in Manchester, one parishioner
said. A 1990 Union Leader report on Manchester Bishop Odore J. Gendron's
retirement mentions Talbot as a long-time friend of Gendron's who recently
appointed Talbot to serve at Catholic Medical Center.
Horion, now one of 65 men and women whose cases are the subject of ongoing
settlement talks with Manchester diocesan attorneys, said no dollar amount
will recover what he has lost.
And no price tag can be placed on what he wants.
"I would like to see the church come back to what it was when I was
a youth -- a leader in the community and. . . able to take the moral high
ground and be looked at with trust and not derision," he explained.
"McCormack will never be able to lead anybody on the moral high ground.
Until the church can find the moral high ground again, they're incapable
of providing leadership," he added.
As attorneys talk settlements, Horion fears the voices of the abused --
and their power to effect real change -- may be lost in the clamor over
money.
"The settlements are not addressing the real issues at the table,"
he explained.
"The fear that I have in this is that the victims right now are being
asked to settle in a vacuum without actually taking a look at the power
we have," Horion added.
"We have not collectively asked the church (for reform) because our
attorneys, this is not their agenda," he said.
Manchester attorney Peter E. Hutchins, who represents Horion and the more
than 60 other unidentified alleged victims in settlement talks that began
Oct. 22, said he is not seeking reforms as conditions in the negotiations.
But he said his clients' decisions to come forward is a powerful impetus
for change in itself.
"They believe by coming forward in the manner in which they have,
in bringing this issue to light, they are helping as part of the process
to quite naturally effect some reforms," Hutchins said.
"But, beyond that, it's not really my function. My job is to represent
my clients and to help them as best as I can, part of that being a financial
compensation, but certainly a heck of a lot more has been helping them
through the last six to eight months," Hutchins added.
Horion wants abusive priests removed from the priesthood, not just from
ministry.
He wants McCormack to resign as bishop and the diocese forced to pay damages
alleged victims incurred by abusive priests while he said church leaders
looked the other way for decades.
He also wants the Manchester diocese to provide full disclosure of its
finances, including the amount it has spent on attorneys to fight alleged
victims' claims. He would like the diocese to set aside the same amount
it spent on legal fees in a fund to pay for mental and physical assistance
to alleged victims.
It particularly pains Horion that many parishioners still regard alleged
victims as either greedy or emotionally weak and unable to get over something
that happened decades ago.
"I ask the parishioners to not see us as the enemy, taking money
from the parishes. . .but welcome us as the prodigal son," Horion
said.
He speaks of a "conspiracy of silence" that enabled priests
to abuse children. This conspiracy extended from the highest reaches of
the diocese to those parents and parishioners in the pews who said nothing,
yet refused to let their children alone with suspect priests, he says.
"They wouldn't have done anything so they wouldn't have to accept
responsibility for putting you in the position of having been abused,"
he said.
Critics wonder if diocese listens to task force advice
By Associated Press
Manchester (NH) Union Leader
November 18, 2002
Concord -- Critics of a task force set up to examine Roman Catholic Church
policies regarding priests accused of sexually abusing children wonder
if the group will be effective.
At the same time, the task force says it is determined to strengthen the
rules aimed at preventing such abuse.
Jeff Blanchard of Concord says there is a sense of openness when the task
force has met with residents at several recent "listening sessions."
But he wonders whether the Diocese of Manchester will heed the advice
the group gives it.
"In the laity, there tends to be a skepticism, a trust that is broken,"
Blanchard said.
Others say the church needs to change its culture as well as its policies.
"I think we need to educate, educate, educate," said Sister
Maureen Sullivan, a theologian at St. Anselm College.
The Rev. Edward Arsenault of the Diocese of Manchester said the church
is committed to responding to the public's concerns in a way that is open
and clear.
Manchester Bishop John B. McCormack last month convened the task force,
chaired by former House Speaker Donna Sytek, to evaluate the diocese's
sexual misconduct policy.
The group has since held "listening sessions" with residents
throughout the state.
Some residents who have attended the meetings have called for McCormack's
resignation in light of revelations that some priests accused of abuse
years ago were shuttled from parish to parish. Others have asked that
the church be more open.
Sytek said she has made sure to pass along all of the comments to McCormack's
office.
"It would be unsatisfactory to me to go out and hear all this other
stuff and not do anything with it," she said. "People are hurting."
Law: Officials should have checked Shanley more
From Staff and wire reports
Manchester (NH) Union Leader
November 20, 2002
Boston -- Cardinal Bernard Law, testifying about his handling of sexual
abuse allegations against retired priest Paul Shanley, acknowledged that
church officials should have done more to investigate Shanley after receiving
complaints about him in 1985 and 1988.
Law's testimony came during a deposition he gave in civil lawsuits filed
against the Archdiocese of Boston in the Shanley case. Transcripts of
the final four days of Law's deposition were made public yesterday; the
first two days were released in August.
Manchester, N.H., Bishop John B. McCormack is also one of the defendants
named in legal action against the archdiocese. He is scheduled to undergo
his fifth day of deposition Friday.
McCormack handled sexual abuse complaints for the archdiocese from 1985
to 1995 and worked directly with Shanley. He succeeded the Rev. Thomas
V. Daily, also now a bishop, whose deposition on Shanley was released
last month. Transcripts of McCormack's testimony will be released after
the deposition is completed, perhaps in December.
In earlier statements, Law blamed poor record-keeping for the archdiocese's
failure to remove Shanley from ministry after allegations were made against
him beginning in 1966.
Law said if he had been aware of the allegations after he came to Boston
in March 1984, he would not have promoted Shanley later that year to pastor
of St. Jean's Parish in Newton, where he allegedly went on to sexually
abuse more boys.
In his deposition testimony released yesterday, Law said church officials
should have done more investigation after receiving complaints that Shanley
had made public comments in favor of man-boy love and had made sexual
overtures toward a mentally ill man at McLean Hospital. Shanley served
as chaplain at the hospital.
After Shanley denied the allegations, church officials took no action.
In the deposition, which was taken in August and October, Law was questioned
by Roderick MacLeish Jr., a lawyer for six men who allege in lawsuits
that Shanley sexually abused them at St. Jean's in the 1980s, after Law
promoted him to pastor.
MacLeish asked, based on the two complaints against Shanley, "should
another step have been taken, Cardinal Law?"
"It would have been much better had another step been taken, yes,"
Law replied.
Robert Banks served as an auxiliary bishop in Boston before being named
bishop of Green Bay, Wis.
The deposition featured numerous testy exchanges between MacLeish and
Law's attorney, J. Owen Todd, as MacLeish pressed Law to explain why Shanley
and many other priests were reassigned to other parishes and not removed
from ministry after the church received allegations of sexual abuse.
Law repeated an explanation he has given repeatedly since the clergy sexual
abuse crisis erupted in January. He said he relied on his subordinates
to review such complaints and on psychological assessments made by mental
health professionals.
"The way in which these matters were handled was through delegation.
My expectation was and is that allegations would be looked at, would be
examined, and that credible allegations would be acted upon, and that
would include getting some kind of a medical assessment, if it seemed
that there was substance to the allegation," Law said.
Law said he did not review Shanley's personnel file to see if it contained
complaints before he promoted Shanley to pastor at St. Jean's.
"My presumption was -- my presumption was that a person in a position
of pastoral responsibility was appropriately there," Law said.
Donna Morrissey, a spokeswoman for the Archdiocese of Boston, did not
immediately return a call seeking comment on the deposition.
Rodney Ford, the father of Gregory Ford, one of the men who claims Shanley
sexually assaulted him at St. Jean's, said he resented Law's comment that
he relied on those who worked for him to investigate complaints against
priests.
"Cardinal Law has to take responsibility for what happened. He's
the leader of our church," Ford said.
In addition to the civil lawsuits, Shanley faces criminal charges. He
has pleaded innocent to 10 counts of child rape and six counts of indecent
assault and battery for allegedly sexually abusing boys from 1979 to 1989
while he was at St. Jean's.
Church task force drafts revised sex abuse policy
By Kathryn Marchocki
Manchester (NH) Union Leader
November 23, 2002
The task force charged with recommending changes to the Catholic Diocese
of Manchester's sexual misconduct policy will move beyond its mandate
and draft a revised policy on its own, the group's chairman said yesterday.
"We hijacked the mandate," former House Speaker Donna P. Sytek
and task force chairman said.
Manchester Bishop John B. McCormack created the task force to review the
diocese's existing policy against the one adopted by the nation's bishops
this month and make recommendations to him for changes.
But Sytek said the 12-member group decided unilaterally to forge ahead
and draft its own policy to present to the bishop.
"It reflects the independence and commitment of the task force,"
she explained. "They are so committed to getting this right that
they don't trust it to anybody else."
Sytek said she expects a skeletal draft containing key elements and recommendations
identified by the task force to be ready by Christmas.
She projected it wouldn't be until mid-March before the task force completes
its revisions and presents a final document to McCormack.
Sytek said she and Diane Murphy Quinlan, an attorney and the diocese's
delegate for policy administration, would write the drafts.
Meanwhile, McCormack was questioned under oath in Manchester yesterday
by attorneys representing alleged abuse victims of Boston archdiocesan
priest the Rev. Paul R. Shanley.
The questioning was part of his continued deposition that began in June.
The bishop is expected to continue to be deposed in connection with civil
suits involving other Boston archdiocesan priests next month.
The task force, formed last month, has heard experts speak on canon law,
clergy sexual abuse and the selection and training of seminarians.
On Thursday, it met privately with the Diocesan Review Board, which reviews
clergy sexual abuse claims, along with a victim of clergy sexual abuse.
Straffod County Attorney Janice Rundles yesterday addressed the group
to give law enforcement's perspective on prosecuting child sexual abuse
cases.
Rundles said child sexual abuse cases are among the most difficult to
prosecute, in part, because they pit one person's word against another's
and often aren't reported until a victim is older when there isn't much
physical evidence available.
The group discussed the issue of whether the state's child abuse and neglect
reporting law requires law enforcement to be notified if the person doesn't
come forward until he or she is 18 or older, or legally an adult.
Rundles said she interprets the law to say the abuse of someone as a child
be reported to civil authorities no matter how old they are.
But Glenna Law, who is in charge of fielding suspected child abuse and
neglect reports for the state Division for Children, Youth and Families,
said her office would not investigate or forward to police a report of
suspected child abuse if the person is 18 and older.
While Law said she would encourage complainants to contact police on their
own, the law does not require her office to report it.
"They are adults at that point and they have the ability to protect
themselves," she explained.
Priest resigns, admits to relationship with minor
By Associated Press
Nashua (NH) Telegraph
November 25, 2002
http://www.nashuatelegraph.com/main.asp?ArticleID=68522&SectionID=25&SubSectionID=354&S=21
Auburn -- A Roman Catholic priest told parishioners he was in love with
an underage girl with whom he had an inappropriate relationship more than
20 years ago.
The Rev. James Haller, 66, resigned Thursday as priest at the St. Peter
Church. He has been barred from functioning as a priest.
A lawyer for the now-grown woman revealed the relationship to Manchester
Diocese lawyers last weekend. She also has met with the state attorney
general’s office.
In his resignation letter Thursday, Haller said he had planned to marry
the girl.
“I was unable to make the decision to leave the priesthood, and
the relationship ended,” he wrote.
The diocese has offered counseling services to the woman and to parishioners.
The relationship occurred before Haller became priest at St. Peter 17
years ago.
In his letter Haller asked parishioners for prayers and forgiveness.
Besides resigning from the priesthood, he resigned from his administrative
position at the Manchester East Deanery.
Neither the attorney general or diocese spokesmen would reveal the girl’s
age at the time of the relationship, except to confirm that she was younger
than 18.
It is the “first and only” report of such misconduct by Haller,
a diocese statement said.
In a statement Saturday, Bishop John McCormack said he was deeply saddened
by the situation.
“While it is difficult to bear this news about someone who in many
other ways has served the church so faithfully, we need to remain faithful
to our commitment that even one instance of abuse of a minor is unacceptable
in priestly ministry,” McCormack said.
Early last week Haller met with Rev. Edward Arsenault, the diocese’s
delegate on sexual misconduct cases. Arsenault said he decided the woman’s
story was credible and recommended to a diocese review board and McCormack
that Haller be banned from functioning as a priest.
McCormack accepted the recommendation. “This case is closed,”
Arsenault told The Union Leader.
Parishioners had mixed views of the news, although few said they were
surprised after many recent revelations about sexual abuse of minors in
the Catholic Church.
“The saddest part of it is that it’s not shocking,”
said a mother picking up her child at the church Saturday. The woman,
who refused to give her name, said the rules need to be changed.
“For God’s sake, let them get married,” she said. “Let
them have a normal life.”
Bishop calls Rev. Haller situation a tragedy
By Benjamin Kepple
Manchester (NH) Union Leader
Nobember 25, 2002
Auburn -- Bishop John B. McCormack told parishioners at St. Peter Catholic
Church yesterday to look to God for guidance as the parish dealt with
revelations surrounding their pastor's removal from the ministry.
On Nov. 21, the Rev. James Haller, 66, resigned as pastor in a letter
to parishioners after allegations surfaced about a relationship he had
with a woman more than 20 years ago. Church officials said the woman was
a minor at the time.
Yesterday, as McCormack spoke, he did so without a bishop's shepherd's
staff or mitre. He said it was somewhat inexplicable that a person could
do such good in the ministry while having done such wrong many years ago.
And, in his homily, he also reminded worshippers that Christ was with
them.
"We walk by faith in him, not by sight, humanly speaking," McCormack
said. "It's not easy, but Christ is with us. And Christ will guide
us if we are open to his way of loving one another."
"We should never feel alone," McCormack said later in his homily.
"But with Him, we shall overcome this, and arise to new and better
life."
Earlier in the service, McCormack spoke more directly to Haller's situation.
He said that Haller had admitted what he had done and was sorry for it,
and pledged that the church would do all it could to help the young woman.
"The whole situation is tragic -- tragic for the woman, tragic for
Father Haller, and tragic for all of us," McCormack said.
McCormack spoke of the situation as a "grave matter." But while
he said the gravity of what was done could not be minimized, Haller's
good work should also not be forgotten.
McCormack also said that staff workers from Catholic Charities would hold
meetings over the next month at the church to help parishioners deal with
what happened. He also noted that the Rev. Bernie Campbell had been appointed
as an interim pastor for the parish.
Campbell, diocesan officials said, would take care of both the administrative
and spiritual needs of the parish until a permanent replacement is named.
McCormack spoke at yesterday's 10 a.m. and 11:30 a.m. Masses, while Auxiliary
Bishop Francis Christian spoke at the 8 a.m. Mass.
It's not the first time McCormack has held Mass at a parish after reported
allegations or revelations of priestly misconduct.
In March, he spoke at St. Joseph Church in Epping after its priest, the
Rev. Ronald Corriveau, was accused of sexual misconduct in the early 1980s.
And in October, McCormack spoke at St. Patrick Church in Jaffrey after
the Rev. Roland Cote was accused of sexual misconduct involving a teenage
boy.
Meanwhile, diocesan spokesman Patrick McGee said that the diocese was
providing some assistance to the woman, who contacted the diocese through
her attorney. But he would not offer any details about what that assistance
entailed, saying the woman wanted to stay anonymous.
"That was her request and we're trying to honor that as best we can,"
McGee said.
McGee also declined to say where Haller had served as a priest prior to
his arrival at St. Peter 17 years ago, although he said Haller had served
as a priest in New Hampshire since he was ordained.
McGee also would not say how old the woman was when the alleged relationship
took place, or what it involved, except to say that she was a minor. Under
church policy, that's under 18 years old.
"It was a relationship with a minor that we felt violated the sexual
misconduct policy of the diocese," McGee said.
Many parishioners leaving St. Peter's 10 a.m. Mass yesterday didn't want
to discuss the matter. Those who did, though, were largely supportive
of Haller. They remembered him for the good work he did while pastor of
St. Peter Church.
"He was a very good priest and I just feel very badly and saddened.
And I forgive him," said Kathy Toomey, of Auburn.
Another female parishioner, who spoke on condition that her name would
not be used, said she was disappointed that Haller had not had the chance
to say good-bye to the congregation.
"I have been tormented since (I found out). Father Haller is a great
guy," she said. "The only mistake I can see is that he fell
in love with a minor."
The woman also took issue with comments made about Haller in Sunday's
edition of The New Hampshire Sunday News, in which another parishioner
referred to Haller in disparaging terms.
Church bullying alleged victims, lawyer says
By J.M. Hirsch, Associated Press
Nashua (NH) Telegraph
November 26, 2002
http://www.nashuatelegraph.com/main.asp?ArticleID=68598&SectionID=25&SubSectionID=354&S=1
Concord, N.H. -- Roman Catholic Church officials are trying to intimidate
36 alleged victims of sexual abuse by priests by declining to help keep
their names confidential, their lawyer said Monday.
Mark Abramson said he has offered to give the names to the Diocese of
Manchester if it agrees to keep them confidential, but has gotten no response
from the diocese’s lawyers.
“They haven’t even given us the courtesy of a reply,”
Abramson said. “Their efforts are very transparent. They are hoping
to try to embarrass or humiliate the victims into not going forward with
their claims.”
Spokesman Pat McGee denied that the diocese is trying to intimidate the
36. He said the door is “always open” to a mediated or negotiated
settlement keeping the names confidential, provided it’s done out
of court.
The 36 sued the diocese anonymously along with 21 of Ambramson’s
clients who are identified by name in court papers.
Abramson stressed that he is not asking the court to keep the names secret,
but for the church to agree not to disseminate the names. Adult victims
of sexual assaults usually are identified in court papers, but news organizations
do not use the names without the victims’ permission.
Abramson said the church’s stance belies its claim that the welfare
of the victims is paramount.
“It’s just another example of how phony their claim is that
all they’re concerned about are the victims,” Abramson said.
“I don’t believe for a second think they are really interested
in helping these victims out,” he said. “They’re interested
in putting the scandal behind them any way they can.”
Bishop John B. McCormack repeatedly has said the church must respect
the confidentiality of victims. In a June deposition in an unrelated lawsuit,
McCormack said victims needed to know they can report allegations to the
church in confidence, without it becoming public and rising “to
the level of a scandal.”
The diocese asked for the names after settlement talks broke down over
money. In an Oct. 3 letter to James Higgins, lawyer for the diocese, Abramson
said he would provide the names as long as the diocese agreed not to make
them public. Higgins has not responded to Abramson and referred calls
for comment to McGee.
Settlement reached in abuse claims
By Albert McKeon
Nashua (NH) Telegraph
November 27, 2002
http://www.nashuatelegraph.com/main.asp?ArticleID=68642&SectionID=25&SubSectionID=354&S=1
The Diocese of Manchester will pay 62 alleged victims of clergy sexual
abuse more than $5 million, the second private settlement reached by the
church in just over a month.
The settlement – announced Tuesday at the diocese’s Manchester
chancery – ends the alleged victims’ legal claims against
28 priests, 11 of whom once served parishes in the Nashua area, and a
brother who had taught at Bishop Guertin High School in Nashua.
Peter Hutchins, a Manchester attorney who represents the 62 people, would
not detail individual settlement amounts from the $5,074,000 package.
But all 62, who claim they suffered abuse as minors, will have enough
money for counseling, a significant purchase and donations to charitable
organizations that help children, the attorney said. One person will support
Catholic Charities, he said.
“We achieved what we hoped to achieve from the beginning: the New
Hampshire solution,” Hutchins said. “I’m very pleased
that we were able to accomplish a settlement of this magnitude without
the need to resort to litigation, with all of the potential harm to victims.”
That New Hampshire solution contrasts with negotiations seen with other
Catholic dioceses, Hutchins said. He and his clients did not encounter
resistance from the Diocese of Manchester in their six months of negotiations,
either through lengthy legal procedures or a refusal to accept victims’
claims, the attorney said.
Some victims made claims in the past month, and because of the timing
of negotiations, gained closure in just a matter of days, Hutchins said.
He has four more open claims that he hopes to settle in the same fashion.
Striking the same tone as attorney Chuck Douglas – who reached
a $950,000 settlement with the diocese last month for 16 men – Hutchins
applauded Bishop John McCormack and diocesan officials for striving to
end negotiations so the alleged victims could start the healing process
outside the glare of the media.
The Rev. Edward Arsenault, the diocesan delegate to the bishop for sexual
misconduct, called the settlement only the beginning of a difficult process
for the alleged victims, who upon their request will have their names
and claims of abuse kept confidential.
“Today is a significant day in the lives of many people who reported
being abused, and in the life of our church, as we help these people move
forward to greater healing of painful events and memories,” Arsenault
said.
Another attorney, however, has broken off talks with the diocese, blaming
church officials for a lack of cooperation. That lawyer, Mark Abramson,
is instead preparing for a trial on behalf of about 60 alleged victims.
To meet the $5 million payment, the diocese’s insurer will provide
$2 million, while $900,000 will come from a diocesan insurance fund reserved
for unanticipated expenses, with the remaining $2,174,000 coming from
a savings account.
As with last month’s agreement, Arsenault stressed that no parish,
school or institutional funds were used in the settlement.
The $2,174,000 represents a considerable sum from the savings account,
Arsenault said, although he would not detail the exact percentage.
All 62 people experienced physical contact by clergy, from grabbing over
clothing to sodomy, Hutchins said. The abuse occurred at churches and
the Catholic camps Fatima and Bernadette, and most of the incidents occurred
before 1979, he said.
None of the 28 priests still has permission to function in ministry,
Arsenault said. The claims also involved two laypersons, who also no longer
have any function with the diocese, Arsenault said.
Eleven of the priests at one time served parishes in the Nashua area,
while Brother Guy Beaulieu taught at Bishop Guertin until 1991. Beaulieu
belonged to the Brothers of the Sacred Heart, the Rhode Island-based religious
order that owns the high school, and also worked at Camp Fatima.
The priests include:
-- Albion Bulger, who served St. Kathryn Church in Hudson from 1969 to
1975, and Parish of the Resurrection in Nashua from 1991 to 2001.
-- Karl Dowd, who served St. Christopher Church in Nashua from 1986 to
2000, and St. Stanislaus Church in Nashua from 1999 to 2000. He was also
director of Camp Fatima and Camp Bernadette. He died in February.
-- Paul Aube, who served St. Louis de Gonzague Church in Nashua in 1975.
-- Albert Boulanger, who served St. Joseph Church in Nashua from 1970
to 1971.
-- Gerard Chalifour, who served Sacred Heart of Jesus Church in Greenville
from 1960 to 1961 and St. Kathryn Church in 1968.
-- Ronald Corriveau, who served St. Joseph Church in 1977, St. Christopher
Church in 1984, and St. Louis de Gonzague in 1985.
-- Robert Densmore, who served St. Christopher Church in 1986.
-- Alfred Janetta, who served Our Lady of Mercy Church in Merrimack in
the 1970s.
-- Francis Lamothe, who served Sacred Heart of Jesus Church in the 1960s.
He died in 1995.
-- Joseph Maguire, who lived at the rectory of St. John the Evangelist
Church in Hudson in 1973.
-- Stephen Scruton, who served St. Kathryn from 1972 to 1973 and St.
John the Evangelist from 1980 to 1983.
NH diocese will pay $5 million to 62 victims
By Mark Hayward
Manchester (NH) Union Leader
November 27, 2002
The Catholic Diocese of Manchester will pay more than $5 million to 62
people who claimed they were abused by priests and other church workers
as minors, church officials announced yesterday.
The incidents took place as long ago as the 1950s and as recently as the
1980s and involved 28 priests, two lay workers and one member of a religious
order, the diocese said in a release.
The diocese disclosed the names of all the priests and lay workers except
three, which the reported victims wanted to be kept confidential, diocesan
officials said.
"None of these men will exercise any pastoral ministries in the church
ever again," said the Rev. Edward J. Arsenault, delegate of the Bishop
for Sexual Misconduct, in a news conference.
Manchester attorney Peter Hutchins, who represented the 62 people, said
no one will receive more than $500,000 and the median settlement was $41,250.
A former House speaker who sits on a diocesan task force reviewing the
policy praised the settlement.
"It shows good faith on the part of the diocese that victims of abuse
will be treated and that their needs will be met," said Donna Sytek,
chairman of the Diocesan Task Force on Sexual Misconduct Policy.
"Compare that with what is going on in Boston," she said in
a telephone interview.
But an activist Catholic who has called for the resignation of Bishop
John B. McCormack said the settlement allows the church hierarchy to keep
secrets internal.
Questions regarding the number of incidents per perpetrator, internal
investigations, coverups and transfers remain undisclosed, said Somersworth
resident James Farrell.
"These are the kind of things we may never find out now as a result
of the settlement," Farrell said.
The diocese did not make any requests for confidentiality in the settlement,
officials stressed.
But at the request of Hutchins' clients, the diocese will not disclose
their names, the details of the abuse or the amounts of individual settlements.
The diocese said that the identities of the accusers has been offered
to the priests and lay workers who are alive.
The $5,074,000 settlement breaks down three ways:
* $2,174,000 comes from unrestricted savings of the diocese. The savings
accumulated from investment returns and unrestricted gifts to the bishop.
* $2 million comes from insurance carriers.
* $900,000 was drawn from the diocesan insurance fund.
Officials stressed that no funds of parishes, schools or institutions
such as New Hampshire Catholic Charities were spent on the settlement.
Parishes and parish-run schools contribute less than 1 percent of their
annual income to the diocesan insurance fund.
Arsenault said he hopes the settlement will help the church restore the
confidence and trust in church leadership.
"While we are using the limited funds available to the diocese, we
must remember that we are doing so in an effort to help people turn to
the Lord and to be healed," Arsenault said.
Hutchins said he represents four others making claims against the diocese,
which he expects will soon be settled. A fifth involves a religious order.
He said all the cases involved some form of physical contact, ranging
from touching over clothes to multiple acts of sodomy.
He praised the Manchester Diocese for its cooperation and said it has
taken a leadership role in dealing with sexual abuse complaints.
During settlement negotiations, diocesan officials did not press for details
such as dates and allegations for every claim, he said.
"I've never seen anything like it," Hutchins said.
Hutchins would not disclose his fee and said he was offended to be asked
such a question.
"I had a pretty good practice before this started. There are a heck
of a lot easier ways to make a buck," he said, "than to sue
your church."
Dan Wise, a spokesman for the New Hampshire Bar Association, said lawyers
typically take personal injury cases on a one-third contingency basis.
Hutchins said the diocese has "absolutely acknowledged that the people
were abused."
Arsenault referred to a three-paragraph statement when asked if the diocese
admits to the allegations.
The statement uses phrases such as "reported incidents," "people
who reported being abused," "complainants" and "persons
accused of misconduct."
Church spokesman Patrick McGee said the settlement shows that the church
recognizes people were harmed and is taking steps to repair their relationship
with the church.
But he stressed that "the harm caused by these people was from individual
actions."
"(McCormack) is sorry that these people have been harmed, there's
no question about it," McGee said.
Hutchins said about a third of his clients want to repair their relationship
with the church, a third want nothing to do with the church and the rest
are in a gray area.
Many plan to give most, if not all, of their settlement money away, Hutchins
said. Some are eyeing organizations that protect children against sexual
abuse. One wants to contribute to Catholic Charities.
He said the settlements will allow his clients to take time off and relax
in a vacation spot if they desire.
Hutchins is the second of three lawyers who have made claims against the
church in the priest sex-abuse scandal to settle.
Last month, Concord lawyer Charles Douglas III engineered a $950,000 settlement
for 16 men.
Meanwhile, lawyer Mark Abramson broke off talks with the church on behalf
of about 60 alleged victims in September. Abramson, who is preparing for
trial, blamed the breakdown on a lack of cooperation from the diocese.
The diocese disclosed the names of all the priests involved in the settlement,
grouped by their status at the time allegations were received:
* Active ministry -- Aime Boisselle, Ronald Corriveau, Alfred Jannetta
and a confidential subject.
* Retired ministry -- Gerard Chalifour and Robert Densmore.
* Extern priest who has left ministry -- Edmond Lemire and Leo Landry.
* Left ministry -- Paul Groleau, Alfred Lapoint, Daniel Osgood and a confidential
subject.
* Dead -- Wilfred Bombadier, Richard Connors, Alfred Constant, Karl Dowd,
Mark Gauthier, Gerald Joyal, Francis Lamothe, Harvey Lamothe, Maurice
Leclerc.
* No permission to minister -- Paul Aube, Albert Boulanger, Albion Bulger,
Joseph Maquire, Stephen Scruton, Leo Shea, Francis Talbot.
* Guy Beaulieu, a member of the Brothers of the Sacred Heart who had no
permission to minister.
* Lay persons no longer employed -- Gerry Dane and a confidential subject.
|