Commission of Investigation Report into the Catholic Archdiocese of Dublin July 2009; released November 26, 2009 This page presents a user-friendly version of a government report on the handling by the Dublin archdiocese of sexual abuse allegations. The report was prepared by Judge Yvonne Murphy, the Commission Chairperson, and Ms Ita Mangan and Mr Hugh O'Neill, Commissioners, and was released on November 26, 2009. The version of the massive report that is presented below provides access to individual chapters, and also offers a linked version of the very helpful index, which can be used to navigate the report and explore its important findings. In keeping with its terms of reference, the Murphy report discussed a "representative sample" of 46 priests, selected from the 172 named priests about whom the Commission received information. The report on the 46 priests, however, was not released intact.

Part 1
     Chapter 1   Overview 1 [redactions restored on December 17, 2010, for this chapter, sections: 26, 38, 42 & 44, and 77]
     Chapter 2   How the Commission carried out its mandate 29
     Chapter 3   The Dublin Archdiocese 43
     Chapter 4   The Role of Canon Law 57 [redactions restored on December 17, 2010, for this chapter, sections: 29, 65-80]
     Chapter 5   Investigation and Prosecution of Child Sexual Abuse 81
     Chapter 6   Health Authorities 99
     Chapter 7   The Framework Document 119 [redactions restored on December 17, 2010, for this chapter, section: 14]
     Chapter 8   The Finances of the Archdiocese 134
     Chapter 9   Insurance 142
     Chapter 10 Education and Formation of Priests 154

Part 2 [red indicates chapters that refer to the accused priest by his real name; other chapters use pseudonyms]
     Chapter 11  Introduction to investigation of the 46 priests 171
     Chapter 12  Fr James McNamee 177
     Chapter 13  Fr Edmondus 188
     Chapter 14  Fr Phineas 210
     Chapter 15  Fr Vidal 212
     Chapter 16  Fr Patrick Maguire 217
     Chapter 17  Fr Ioannes 239
     Chapter 18  Fr Tyrus 250
     Chapter 19  [Text entirely redacted] 252 [Chapter 19   Fr Jovito, previously redacted, was released on December 17, 2010]
     Chapter 20  Fr [Text partially redacted] 282
     Chapter 21  Fr Horatio 344
     Chapter 22  Fr Donal Gallagher 353
     Chapter 23  Fr Hugo 360
     Chapter 24  Fr Ivan Payne 363
     Chapter 25  Fr Donato 386
     Chapter 26  Fr Harry Moore 390
     Chapter 27  Fr Septimus 400
     Chapter 28  Fr William Carney 414
     Chapter 29  Fr Thomas Naughton 455
     Chapter 30  Fr Cicero 470
     Chapter 31  Fr Clemens 478
     Chapter 32  Fr Dominic Savio Boland 482
     Chapter 33  Fr Quinton 494
     Chapter 34  Fr Marius 506
     Chapter 35  Fr Noel Reynolds 514 [redactions restored on December 17, 2010, for this chapter, section: 52]
     Chapter 36  Fr Daryus 529
     Chapter 37  Fr Terentius 532
     Chapter 38  Fr John Kinsella 544
     Chapter 39  Fr Laurentius 547
     Chapter 40  Fr Klaudius 558
     Chapter 41  Fr Francis McCarthy 565 [redactions restored on December 17, 2010, for this chapter, section: 13]
     Chapter 42  Fr Sergius 575
     Chapter 43  Fr Dante 581
     Chapter 44  Fr Cassius 590
     Chapter 45  Fr Giraldus 592
     Chapter 46  Fr Aquila 598
     Chapter 47  Fr Blaise 601
     Chapter 48  Fr Benito 603
     Chapter 49  Fr Magnus 611
     Chapter 50  Fr Jacobus 613
     Chapter 51  Fr Guido 617
     Chapter 52  Fr Rufus 621
     Chapter 53  Fr Ignatio 626
     Chapter 54  Fr Cornelius 629
     Chapter 55  Fr Ricardus 631
     Chapter 56  Fr Augustus 635
     Chapter 57  Fr Ezio 637
     Chapter 58  Complainants 639

Appendices
     Appendix 1 Time Line 649
     Appendix 2 Law on sexual offences 655
     Appendix 3 Glossary of Terms 672
     Appendix 4 Map of the Archdiocese of Dublin 677
     Appendix 5 Bibliography 679
     Appendix 6 Commission personnel 681

Index 683

INDEX

Note: Names in bold indicate priests in the representative sample
An asterisk* after a name denotes a pseudonym
References are to chapter number followed by paragraph number

[BishopAccountability.org has linked each chapter number in the index to a PDF of the chapter. For example, in the first index entry below, "administrative leave" is listed as being discussed at 4.45-4.50, which means Chapter 4, paragraphs 45 through 50. In order to read those paragraphs, remember the paragraph numbers 45-50, click on the Chapter number 4, and then scroll through Chapter 4 to paragraph 45.

Use the linked letters below to jump easily to a section of the index and look up a particular word or phrase.

A   B   C   D   E   F   G   H   I   J   K   L   M   N   O   P   Q   R   S   T   U   V   W  ]

A
administrative leave, 4.45-4.50
Advisory Committee on Extra-Diocesan Priests, 33.4
advisory panel. see child protection advisory panel (Dublin Archdiocese)
Africa, 29.1, 39.1, 39.21
Alameda (Santa Fe), 20.62
Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), 28.68, 28.77, 28.81, 37.25, 37.40, 37.41
Allianz Group, 9.1
altar boys, complaints concerning, 12.5, 12.21, 16.12, 17.6, 20.4-20.8, 20.5, 20.15-20.17, 20.36, 20.88, 22.3, 22.14, 24.46, 28.29-28.32, 29.30, 31.2, 36.5, 41.19, 42.14, 43.2, 43.4, 43.11, 50.2, 50.3
American Canon Law Association, 4.31
American Conference of Bishops, 3.42
anonymous complaints, 1.29, 4.35
apologies, 13.49, 16.58, 58.20, 58.23
Aquila*, Fr, 46.1-46.11
Aran Quay parish, 12.4
Archbishop McQuaid Charitable Trust, 8.22
Archbishop McQuaid Curial Trust, 8.22
Archbishop Walsh Charitable Trust, 8.22
archbishops of Dublin, 1.16, 1.31, 1.64, 11.13. see also individual archbishops
     awareness of complaints, 1.19-1.21
     failure to report to Gardai, 1.32
     handling of complaints, 1.36-1.46, 3.18-3.23
     legal status, 3.8
     management ability, 1.55
     metropolitan archbishop, role as, 3.13, 3.14
archdiocesan documents. see also secret archive
684
discovery process, 2.17-2.35
Garda access to, 5.27-5.33
legal privilege, 2.25-2.32, 5.30-5.31
shredding of, 15.17-15.18
Archdiocese of Dublin. see Dublin Archdiocese
archives. see secret archive
Arran Quay parish, 52.3
Artane Industrial School, 26.3, 26.17
Attorney General of Massachusetts, 1.28, 1.108, 1.110
audits, 7.50-7.51
Aughrim Street parish, 29.1, 29.38
Augustus*, Fr, 56.1-56.9
auxiliary bishops (Dublin Archdiocese), 1.31, 1.56, 1.67, 3.17, 3.18, 3.19, 11.13
     awareness of clerical sex abuse, 1.22, 3.23
     handling of complaints, 1.47-1.54. see also individual bishops
     role and responsibilities, 1.56-1.59
Ayrfield parish, 16.27, 28.17, 28.25, 28.27-28.36, 28.39, 28.43, 28.64, 28.68, 28.74, 28.75, 28.87, 28.100, 28.104, 28.105, 28.118, 28.127

B
Balcurris, Ballymun, 16.24
Baldoyle, 28.80
Ballyfermot parish, 41.8, 41.15, 41.24
Ballyfermot Vocational School, 28.4
Barr judgment, 6.31
Bayside parish, 26.14, 26.41
Belmont Park Hospital, Waterford, 28.84, 28.87, 28.90
Benedict XVI, Pope, 3.45
Benito*, Fr, 1.65, 48.1-48.32
Bergin, Liam, 1.14n
bishops. see also auxiliary bishops; Irish Catholic Bishops' Conference; individual
bishops
     accountability and autonomy, 3.15-3.16
     coadjutor bishops, 3.17
     metropolitan's supervisory role over, 3.13, 3.14
     oath of fidelity, 1.23, 3.28
Blaise*, Fr, 47.1-47.8
Boland, Fr Dominic Savio, 1.69, 1.78, 17.21, 32.1-32.54
     Commission's assessment, 32.49-32.54
Bonnybrook parish, 35.15
Boston Archdiocese (USA), 1.28, 1.108, 1.110, 3.7
Brannick, Dr Teresa, 11.4, 11.5
Brentwood diocese (England), 4.19
Briscoe, Msgr Peter, 10.9, 10.13, 10.17
Brittas Bay, Co. Wicklow, 12.21, 20.7
Browne, Msgr Michael, 28.67, 28.68, 28.69, 28.73, 28.76, 28.77
Byrne (Garda superintendent), 28.51, 28.54

C
Cabinteely parish, 26.15
Cabra parish, 24.2, 24.28
California (USA), 6.54, see also individual dioceses
Camon, Sean (garda superintendent), 5.26, 5.28, 5.31, 5.33
Canadian Canon Law Society, 4.31
canon law, 1.15, 1.18, 3.10, 3.14, 3.34-3.35, 3.40, 3.44, 4.1-4.94, 33.37, 35.16, 39.35
     civil law, and, 4.5
     codification, 4.7-4.8
     defamation, 24.29
     formation of priests, 10.3-10.4, 10.16-10.17
     incardination, rules on, 33.14, 33.15
     penalties for failure to apply, 4.81
     revision, 4.9-4.10, 4.13
     role of, 4.1-4.3
     rules regarding child sexual abuse, 1.17, 1.25-1.26, 4.30-4.64
          application of penalties, 4.52-4.55
          Crimen Solicitationis (1922/1962), 4.18-4.28
          failure to implement, 1.25, 4.88, 4.90
          imputability, concept of, 4.56-4.61, 4.93
          initial inquiry, 4.38
          penal provisions, 1.25, 1.26, 1.30, 4.11, 4.65-4.72, 4.90 see also canonical trials
          preliminary investigation, 4.39-4.50
          prescription/limitation periods, 4.62-4.64
          procedural requirements, 4.17-4.29
          reform/pastoral care, 4.53-4.55, 4.90
          removal of faculties, 4.51
          Sacramentorum Sanctitatis Tutela (2001), 4.29
          secrecy/confidentiality, obligation of, 1.27-1.33, 4.82-4.86
          'semblance of truth,' requirement of, 4.29, 4.38
          status of accused person, 4.45-4.50
     selective use of, 4.3
     status and influence of, 1.25, 4.1, 4.5, 4.11-4.15
     translation, 4.31
     uncertainty/lack of precision, 4.87-4.93
The Canon Law: Letter & Spirit (1995), 4.31
Canon Law Association of Great Britain and Ireland, 24.32
Canon Law Society of Great Britain and Ireland, 4.31, 4.59
canonical precepts, 4.51, 12.35, 27.22, 27.28, 27.36, 34.26, 43.21, 48.22
canonical trials, 1.26, 4.65-4.72, 28.118-28.122
     appeals to Rome from,
     conduct of, 4.69-4.72
     confidentiality/secrecy, obligation of, 4.82-4.86
     damages, 4.73
Cappaghmore (Clondalkin), 28.109, 28.115, 28.117, 28.123
Capuchin Order, 32.1. see also Boland, Fr Dominic Savio
Cardinal Secrets (Prime Time, 2002), 2.18, 5.12, 12.37, 17.36, 29.52, 41.41
Carmelite monastery, Delgany, 1.66, 12.21, 12.30, 12.38, 12.49
Carney, Fr William (Bill), 1.38, 1.42, 1.44, 1.52, 1.64, 1.77, 1.89, 1.92, 4.29, 4.54, 16.2, 16.25, 16.29, 28.1-28.149
     Commission's assessment, 28.130-28.149
Carroll, Joseph (auxiliary bishop, 1968-1989), 11.13, 30.10, 33.4
      handling of complaints, 28.76, 28.78, 28.80, 28.81
Carroll, Fr Patrick, 8.1, 8.2
Cassius*, Fr, 44.1- 44.10
Catholic Church. see Church authorities; Dublin Archdiocese; Rome/Vatican
Catholic Youth Care programme, 3.4
celibacy, 10.18, 18.1, 18.2, 18.5, 39.6, 56.1, 56.4
chancellery (Dublin Archdiocese), 4.21
     chancellors, 1.60-1.62, 11.13. see also individual chancellors
     role and functions, 3.34-3.37
     secret archive, 3.35
Channel Four, 38.3
Child Abuse Guidelines (1987), 6.71
Child Care Act 1991, 1.99, 6.19, 6.21-6.32
     health boards, duties of, 6.21-6.24, 6.27
child protection advisory panel (Dublin Archdiocese), 3.53, 3.54, 7.21-7.31
     Commission's view on, 7.40-7.43
     complainants, involvement with, 7.31, 7.41
     composition, 7.22
     guidelines, 7.26-7.39
     implementation of recommendations of, 7.29-7.30
     investigations and reports, 12.32-12.35, 13.47, 21.29, 26.26, 27.17-27.19, 31.14, 33.24, 34.26-34.27, 35.23, 43.20, 45.2, 46.8, 48.20-48.21, 48.25, 50.12, 55.6, 55.9
     procedure, 7.24-7.25
     pseudonyms, use of, 7.27
     role and remit, 7.21, 7.23
child protection legislation, 1.99, 1.100, 6.4, 6.7-6.32, 6.8
     Child Care Act 1991, 6.21-6.31
     Children Act 1989, 6.17
     'fit person' procedure. see Children Act 1908
     government task force, 6.10-6.13
     Health Acts, 6.9, 6.26
Child Protection Notification System (CPNS), 6.74
child protection responsibilities
     health authorities, 6.21-6.31
     State, 1.99-1.100, 6.8, 6.10
Child Protection Service (Dublin Archdiocese), 1.16, 3.37, 11.13
     establishment, 3.51
     funding of, 8.11
     individual cases, and, 14.3, 18.6, 28.128, 29.10, 34.31, 36.12, 43.18-43.21, 45.4-45.6, 45.10, 45.12, 45.14, 45.15,45.21, 45.22, 48.26, 48.28, 48.31, 52.19, 54.6, 55.13
     personnel, functions of, 3.55, 3.56, 3.57, 3.58
     role and functions, 3.52-3.60
     support services for victims, 8.11-8.12
child protection services (health authorities), 6.5. see also social work service
     awareness of child sex abuse, 6.52-6.54
     child sex abuse assessment units, 6.54, 6.56
     community care programme, 6.42-6.51
     development of, 6.37-6.54
     handling of abuse complaints, 6.55-6.57
     health boards, 6.42-6.50
     HSE, 6.51
     staff shortages, 6.56-6.57
child protection trainers, 7.52
child sexual abuse, 2.9
     definition, 2.9
     guidelines. see guidelines on child sexual abuse
     training of priests, as factor in, 10.19-10.31
     treatment of offenders. see treatment for clerical offenders
Child Sexual Abuse: Framework for a Church Response. see Framework Document (1996)
Children Act 1908, 6.8, 6.11, 6.19
     'fit person' procedure, 6.9, 6.12, 6.17, 6.39
Children First guidelines (1999), 2.9, 5.22, 6.73-6.74
Children's Acts, 28.10
children's homes. see residential institutions
Children's University Hospital, Temple St, 2.10, 6.54, 6.56
Church & General Insurance Company, 9.1, 9.4, 20.100. see also insurance
Church authorities. see also canon law; Dublin Archdiocese; Irish Catholic Bishops'
Conference; religious orders; Rome/Vatican
     awareness of clerical child sex abuse, 1.18-1-23
     canon law rules, and. see also canon law
     failure to implement, 1.25, 4.88, 4.90
     ignorance of, 4.87
     Commission, contact with, 2.10
     communications between, 1.63-1.69
     cover-up by, 1.35, 1.113
     initiatives by, 7.44-7.57. see also child protection advisory panel; Child Protection Service; Framework Document (1996)
     offending priests, dealing with, 1.81-1.86
     'pastoral approach,' 4.90
     penal process. see canonical trials
     reputations, concern for, 1.15, 1.30
     State authorities, communications with, 1.101
     State enforcement of child protection, and, 1.100
Church courts, 4.11. see also canonical trials
Church law. see canon law
Church of Ireland, 10.36
Churchill, Fr Paul, 7.17, 7.22
Cicero*, Fr, 1.54, 30.1-30.29
     Commission's assessment, 30.24-30.29
Cistercian Order, 35.20, 35.22
civil legal actions, 12.29, 12.36, 13.68, 17.15, 36.11, 44.9, 47.4, 47.5, 52.21, 58.28- 58.29
Cleary, Fr (Vincentian), 22.9, 22.10
Clemens*, Fr, 31.1-31.16
     Commission's assessment, 31.16
clerical child sex offenders, 1.13, 1.34
     advisory panel guidelines. see child protection advisory panel (Dublin Archdiocese)
     canon law rules for dealing with. see canon law
     complaints against. see complaints
     contacts between, 1.76-1.80, 21.22
     criminal convictions. see criminal convictions
     criminal investigations. see Garda investigations
     current situation, 8.31, 11.7
     diocesan priests, 1.13
     false accusations. see false accusations
     financial provision for, 8.17-8.31
     guilty pleas, 1.11, 11.10
     imputability, concept of, 4.56-4.61
     laicisations. see laicisation
     legal fees, 8.30
     monitoring. see monitoring of clerical offenders number, 1.8
     options for, 4.45-4.80, 7.33
     privileged access to children, 4.2
     re-admission to ministry. see return to ministry
     religious orders, members of, 1.13, 1.84. see also religious orders
     representative sample. see representative sample; individual names [in bold]
     reputation of, concerns for, 1.30
     transfers of, 1.66
     treatment. see treatment for clerical offenders
Clerical Fund Society, 8.14, 8.18-8.22, 8.31, 21.29, 24.73, 29.46, 35.35, 42.18, 43.24
Clogher Road parish, 20.43-20.55, 20.63, 28.24, 28.87, 28.91-28.94, 28.99, 28.101, 28.106, 28.109, 28.115
Clonliffe College, 5.32, 10.1, 10.32, 20.18, 20.86, 24.28, 28.3, 28.81, 32.4, 34.5, 34.6, 35.2, 35.19
     administration, 10.1
     admission requirements, 10.3-10.7
     children's homes, students' visits to, 28.8, 28.13, 41.9-41.11
     formation of priests. see education/formation of priests
Clonskeagh parish, 28.67, 28.73, 28.76
Clontarf, 20.82
Cloyne diocese, 2.3
coadjutor bishops, 3.17
Code of Canon Law (1983), 4.6
College of Consultors, 3.30
Collins, Marie, 13.1, 13.76, 13.77, 13.79
     evidence to Commission, 13.19-13.22, 58.19-58.21, 58.30
     meeting with Archbishop Connell, 13.48-13.49, 58.20
     reporting of abuse, 13.12-13.13, 13.23-13.25, 13.38-13.42
Columban Fathers, 1.22, 4.78-4.80, 16.1. see also Maguire, Fr Patrick
     Policy on Sexual Abuse of Minors, 16.40
Comiskey, Brendan (auxiliary bishop, 1980-1984), 1.22, 1.48, 3.21, 11.13, 26.10
Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse. see Ryan Commission; Ryan Report
Commissions of Investigation Act 2004, 2.3, 2.10, 2.14, 2.17, 2.25, 2.42
Committee on Child Abuse (Irish Bishops' Conference), 7.45-7.48
Committee on Industrial and Reformatory Schools. see Kennedy Report (1970)
Common Fund, 8.13-8.14, 8.16
community care programme (health authorities), 6.42-6.57
     DCC (director of community care), 6.42, 6.46, 6.55
compensation to victims, 1.106, 4.3, 17.20, 41.2, 41.20. see also settlements with victims
     Dublin Archdiocese, payments from, 8.3-8.4
     insurance cover. see insurance
     Payne case, 24.75-24.78
     Stewardship Trust, 8.5-8.10
complainants, 1.102-1.106, 2.11, 2.12, 6.3, 58.1-58.30
     archdiocesan support services for, 8.11-8.12
     betrayal, sense of, 58.14-58.21
     child protection advisory panel, and, 7.31, 7.41
     Church authorities, treatment by, 1.35, 7.18-7.20, 58.14-58.21
          post-1995, 58.23-58.30
     civil proceedings. see civil legal actions
     Commission, contacts with, 2.11-2.12
     compensation for. see compensation
     concerns of, 4.2
     counselling for. see counselling
     delay in making complaint. see delay
     false accusations by. see false accusations
     families, effect on, 58.10-58.13
     fear of not being believed, 58.8-58.9
     gender ratio, 1.10, 11.12
     relationship difficulties, 58.2
     religious belief, effect on, 58.3
     reporting of complaints, 58.22
     settlements. see settlements with victims
     stated effects of abuse, 58.5-58.7
     support structures, 1.111
     transference of guilt, 58.4
     victim charter, 5.7
complaints, 11.9-11.12
     anonymous, 1.29, 4.35
     archdiocesan personnel dealing with, 11.13
     Church authorities, treatment by, 1.29
     false accusations. see false accusations
     late complaints, 11.5
     number of, 1.8-1.12, 1.109, 11.1, 11.9
     representative sample. see representative sample
     time periods, 1.19
Conference of Religious of Ireland (CORI), 3.39, 8.12
confidentiality/secrecy, 1.15
     canon law, requirement in, 1.27-1.33, 4.25-4.27, 4.82-4.86. see also secret archive
     Commission memorandum on, 2.14
     shredding of documents, 15.17-15.18
Congregation for Catholic Education for Seminaries and Educational Institutions, 10.34
Congregation for the Clergy (Rome), 3.45, 7.13
Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (Rome), 1.18, 3.45, 4.69, 20.145, 20.148, 27.36
     Commission's contacts with, 2.23, 2.24
     referral of sex abuse allegations to, 4.29
Connell, Desmond (Archbishop of Dublin, 1988-2004), 1.23, 1.26, 1.36, 1.42-1.46, 1.50, 1.66, 3.17, 3.24, 3.45, 4.65, 4.88, 5.15-5.16, 7.3, 7.15, 7.21, 9.24, 17.11, 17.36, 20.99
     advisory panel recommendations, implementation of, 7.29-7.30
     canonical advisers, 4.21
     Garda investigations, and, 5.28, 5.33
     handling of complaints, 3.22, 12.22, 12.25, 12.49, 13.15-13.18, 13.22, 13.24, 13.35, 13.72-13.75, 17.44, 21.9, 21.18, 22.23, 23.9, 25.11, 25.12, 26.18-26.23, 29.41-29.42, 30.15, 30.18, 30.23, 33.14, 33.16, 33.19, 33.21, 33.24, 33.26, 33.34, 34.4, 34.8, 34.25, 35.16, 35.20, 35.27, 35.28, 35.34-35.35, 36.12, 37.26, 38.13, 41.25, 41.35, 42.9, 42.15, 42.17, 43.5, 43.12, 46.4, 46.6, 48.5, 48.19, 48.27, 48.30, 49.3, 50.12, 55.5, 58.20
          Carney case, 28.99, 28.101-28.106, 28.109, 28.114, 28.127
          Payne case, 24.3, 24.29, 24.33, 24.37, 24.40, 24.47, 24.53, 24.59, 24.62-24.64, 24.63, 24.69-24.70, 24.75-24.78, 24.80-24.81, 58.20
          Septimus case, 27.1, 27.9, 27.19, 27.22, 27.28, 27.35-27.36, 27.39
     legal privilege issue, and, 2.28, 2.29, 2.33-2.35
     medical experts, views on, 24.22
     meetings with victims, 13.48-13.49, 29.41
     reporting of complaints to Gardaí, 1.96, 13.24
     statements on child abuse, 13.55
Connolly, Msgr, 10.38
Constitution of Ireland, 5.50, 5.55, 5.61
Cooney, Dr John, 20.151, 20.152, 20.155, 28.60, 28.64, 28.65, 28.72, 28.75, 28.81, 28.84
Cornelius*, Fr, 54.1-54.7
Costigan, Garda Commissioner, 1.92, 13.5
Council of Priests, 3.29
counselling, 7.20, 7.42
cover-up by Church authorities, 1.35, 1.113
CPS. see Child Protection Service (Dublin Archdiocese)
Crimen Solicitationis (1922 and 1962), 2.23, 4.6, 4.18-4.28
     Dublin Archdiocese, use in, 4.21-4.24
     procedural requirements, 4.25-4.28
     secrecy requirement, 4.25-4.27
criminal convictions, 11.10, 13.53-13.54, 16.56-16.69, 24.69, 26.33, 29.39, 32.38, 38.11, 41.38
Criminal Law Act 1976, 55.12
Criminal Law Act 1997, 5.38
Criminal Law (Amendment) act 1885, 39.18
criminal proceedings. see Director of Public Prosecutions; Garda investigations
Crosscare programme, 3.4
Crumlin children's hospital. see Our Lady's Hospital for Sick Children, Crumlin
Crumlin garda station, 12.27
Crumlin parish, 12.4, 12.10-12.36, 12.46
culture of secrecy. see confidentiality/secrecy
Cunnane, Joseph (archbishop of Tuam), 35.13, 35.14
Curial Trust, 8.3, 8.12, 8.22-8.25, 8.26, 8.31, 24.73, 24.78
Curley, Fr Con, 20.64, 20.65, 20.66, 20.92, 20.95-20.96, 20.102
Curtin, Msgr Jerome, 11.13, 12.16, 26.25, 26.27, 28.68
Cyproterone Acetate, 20.72

D
Dante*, Fr, 43.1-43.27
     Commission's assessment, 43.25-43.27
Daryus*, Fr, 36.1-36.13
     Commission's assessment, 36.13
Daughters of the Heart of Mary. see St Joseph's orphanage, Tivoli Road
deaneries, 3.25
Decalogue (Ten Commandments), 4.32
defamation, 24.58, 27.29
     civil and church law, differences between, 24.29
delay, 12.28, 17.22, 27.44, 32.8, 32.54, 36.10, 39.14, 53.13
     complainant delay, 5.46, 5.52-5.60
     fair procedures, and, 5.50-5.62
     prosecutorial delay, 5.61-5.62
     test to be applied, 5.59
Delgany, Co. Wicklow. see Carmelite monastery, Delgany
Department of Education and Science, 2.10, 41.37, 41.43
Department of Health and Children, 2.9, 2.10, 6.55
     child abuse guidelines, 5.21-5.22, 6.68-6.76, 29.34. see also Children First guidelines (1999)
Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform, 5.7
Depo-Provera, 20.67-20.72
diocesan curia, 3.35
Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), 2.10, 2.17, 5.1, 5.44-5.65, 21.8, 48.18, 53.12
     Carney case, 28.32, 28.51, 28.53, 28.127
     change of mind by, 5.65, 35.49
     decisions not to prosecute, 5.45-5.46, 12.28, 17.22, 22.21, 27.16, 27.42, 27.44, 28.127, 29.38, 31.14, 32.8, 32.54, 36.10, 39.14, 42.6, 45.18, 46.3, 48.24, 53.13, 55.11
     delay and fair procedures, 5.46, 5.50-5.62. see also delay
     independence, 5.48
     prejudice, assessment of, 5.63-5.64
     prosecution of clerical offenders, 5.49, 20.108-20.111, 24.66, 27.42-27.45, 28.53, 32.35
     prosecutorial delay, 5.61-5.62
     submission of garda file to, 5.5-5.6, 20.108
Discalced Carmelites, 11.15
discovery of documents, 2.17-2.36
     HSE, Commission's dealings with, 6.60-6.66
     legal challenge, 2.33-2.35
     legal privilege, 2.25-2.32
     religious orders, 2.36
     Rome, documents held by, 2.23-2.24
dismissal from clerical state, 1.26, 4.56, 28.120
documents. see also archdiocesan documents; discovery of documents; HSE
Vatican, held by, 2.23-2.24
Dolan, Msgr John (chancellor, 1997-), 4.2, 4.11, 4.12, 4.23, 4.29, 4.41, 4.84, 4.85, 7.2, 7.43, 11.13, 17.34, 25.12, 47.2
     Framework Document (1996), and, 7.12-7.14, 7.17-7.19
     handling of complaints, 16.52, 20.168, 21.15, 21.20-21.21, 23.11, 24.67, 24.72, 26.17, 26.41, 27.31, 27.33, 30.18, 30.20, 31.13, 32.32, 35.29, 36.8, 36.13, 37.35, 41.34, 41.39, 43.4, 43.6-43.8, 44.5, 48.17, 48.19, 55.4, 55.5, 55.7-55.9
Domestic Violence/Sexual Assault Investigation Unit (DVSAIU), 5.6, 5.10-5.12
Donaghmede parish, 28.87
Donato*, Fr, 25.1-25.17
     Commission's assessment, 25.14-25.17
Donnycarney parish, 1.66, 29.9, 29.12, 29.13-29.25, 29.36, 29.54, 29.55
Doran, Fr Kevin, 10.10
Doyle, Fr Thomas, 4.48
DPP. see Director of Public Prosecutions
Drennan, Martin (auxiliary bishop, 1997-2005), 11.13, 51.1-51.2
Drimnagh, 23.2, 23.4, 24.1
Drogheda, Co. Louth. see St Vincent's industrial school
drug therapy, 20.67-20.72, 20.151
Dublin Archdiocese, 1.14-1.16, 1.90, 2.17, 3.1-3.49, 3.24
     activities of, 3.4
     Ad Limina reports, 3.47, 3.48
     archbishops. see archbishops of Dublin; individual archbishops
     auxiliary bishops. see auxiliary bishops; individual bishops
     chancellery. see chancellery
     Commission's dealings with, 1.87-1.89, 2.10
     communications, 1.64-1.69
     consultative bodies, 3.29-3.30
     documents and files, access to. see archdiocesan documents
     finances of. see finances of Dublin Archdiocese
     handling of complaints, 1.29, 1.30-1.31, 1.35, 1.81-1.86, 3.18-3.24. see also child protection advisory panel; Child Protection Service
          awareness of abuse, 1.14, 1.17-1.24
          canon law rules, and, 4.1-4.94
          comparisons with other dioceses, 1.107-1.112
          cover-up, 1.113
          Framework Document (1996), and, 7.15-7.20
          Garda, contacts with, 5.13-5.18
          legal status, 3.5-3.8
          offending priests, dealing with, 1.81-1.86, 4.47-4.72, 4.90. see also canonical trials; individuals in representative sample [names in bold]
          personnel involved, 11.13. see also individual officeholders
          priorities in, 1.15, 1.30, 1.113
          reporting to civil authorities. see reporting of complaints
          secrecy, culture of, 1.27-1.33, 4.82-4.86
          treatment of complainants. see complainants
     management of, 1.55-1.62, 3.9-3.16
     parishes, 3.3
     population, 3.2, 3.3
     priests, 3.3, 3.26-3.33. see also priests
     religious orders, communications with, 1.69
     structures and procedures, 1.16
     Vatican/Rome, relationship with, 3.44-3.49
     vicars forane (deans), 3.25
Dublin Archdiocese Commission of Investigation. see Dublin Commission
Dublin bombings (1974), 20.129
Dublin Circuit Court, 29.39
Dublin Commission, 1.7, 1.8
     appointment, 2.1
     church authorities, dealings with, 1.87-1.89, 2.10
     complainants, contacts with, 2.11-2.12
     costs of, 2.42
     definition of child sexual abuse, 2.9
     discovery process. see discovery of documents
     establishment, 1.1, 2.5-2.7
     function of, 1.4
     hearings, 2.14-2.16
     investigation of representative sample. see representative sample
     Memorandum on Confidentiality, 2.14
     practice and procedure, 2.13
     preliminary inquiries, 2.10
     report, 2.40
     research, 2.38-2.39
     terms of reference, 2.2-2.3, 2.8
     time period under investigation, 2.2
Dublin Corporation, 6.33
Dublin County Council, 6.33
Dublin Diocesan Clerical Fund Society. see Clerical Fund Society
Dublin Diocesan Directory, 20.172
Dublin Diocesan Guidebook, 13.35
Dublin Diocesan Pilgrimage to Lourdes, 49.1, 51.1, 51.5, 51.6
Dublin Health Authority, 6.33, 6.40-6.41, 28.11
Dublin Metropolitan Region (DMR), 5.3
Dublin Metropolitan Tribunal, 16.61, 16.64, 16.73
Dublin Regional Marriage Tribunal, 3.37, 24.2, 24.4, 24.29, 24.40, 24.47, 24.54, 30.1, 30.2, 30.9, 30.18, 30.19, 30.20
Duffy, Fr Aquinas, 21.21, 52.14, 52.15
Dunlavin parish, 28.13, 41.1, 41.8, 41.12-41.17, 41.34, 41.37
Dunne, Patrick (auxiliary bishop, 1946-1984), 11.13
     investigation of complaints, 12.6, 13.6, 13.8, 13.11, 13.69, 13.70

E
Eadestown parish, 20.6
East Wall parish, 35.10-35.11, 35.19, 35.48
Eastern Health Board (EHB), 6.33, 6.36, 6.56, 13.36, 28.5, 28.6, 28.11, 40.18-40.19, 40.36, 41.34
     child protection services, 6.42-6.48
     childcare manager, role of, 6.47-6.48
     community care programme, 6.42-6.48
     social worker service, 6.42, 6.43, 6.47, 6.48
Eastern Regional Health Authority (ERHA), 6.34, 6.36, 6.49, 6.50
Edenmore parish, 13.14, 13.35, 13.43-13.44, 13.51, 13.74, 26.8
Edmondus*, Fr, 1.37, 1.89, 1.92, 3.18, 4.21, 13.1-13.83
     Commission's assessment, 13.69-13.83
Education Fund (Dublin Archdiocese), 8.22
education/formation of priests, 10.1-10.38
     celibacy, training in, 10.18
     child sexual abuse, education on issues of, 10.19-10.31
     Clonliffe College, 10.1-10.31
     current position, 10.32-10.35
     eligibility and admission, 10.3-10.7
     evaluation during formation, 10.11
     Framework Document recommendations, 10.21-10.28
     Garda vetting, 10.10
     homosexual ideation, and, 10.32, 10.34, 10.37-10.38
     Maynooth College, 10.32, 10.33, 10.36-10.38
     Our Children Our Church, recommendations of, 10.31
     pastoral placement, 10.12-10.14, 10.22
     programme of training, 10.2
     psychological assessment, 10.8-10.9, 10.19, 10.21, 10.34
     screening of candidates, 10.21, 10.34-10.35
     sexual activity, 10.32
     sexual history, consideration of, 10.32
     sexuality, and, 10.18, 10.32
     spiritual director, 10.15-10.17
EHB. see Eastern Health Board
Elliot, Ian, 7.55
Enniskerry, Co. Wicklow, 38.1, 38.6, 41.8
Episcopal Conference. see Irish Catholic Bishops' Conference
episcopal vicars, 3.11, 8.1, 11.13
Eureka (California), 20.78-20.79, 20.127
Ezio*, Fr, 57.1-57.5

F
fair procedures, delay and. see delay
false accusations, 1.12, 11.11, 55.1. see also Ricardus*, Fr
     criminal proceedings against complainant, 55.12
False Recovered Memory Syndrome, 53.5
Faoiseamh Helpline, 7.20, 7.42, 8.12, 43.9, 52.15, 55.7
Ferns diocese, 1.79, 3.13, 4.50, 24.47
Ferns inquiry, 3.15, 4.50
Ferns Report, 1.95, 1.107, 2.2, 5.8, 6.25, 6.27, 6.31, 10.32
Field, Raymond (auxiliary bishop, 1997-), 1.23, 1.65, 3.24, 11.13, 21.21, 21.28, 42.10, 42.16, 42.19
     investigation of complaints, 48.5-48.6, 48.11, 48.15-48.21, 48.29
finances of Dublin Archdiocese, 8.1-8.31
     assets, management of, 3.6
     clerical child sex abusers, support for, 8.17-8.31
     compensation to victims, 8.3-8.10
     support services for victims, 8.11-8.12
     supports for priests, 8.13-8.31, 24.55. see also Clerical Fund Society
'fit person' procedure. see Children Act 1908
Forristal, Laurence (auxiliary bishop, 1980-1981), 1.22, 1.54, 1.59, 7.2, 11.13, 12.10, 12.43, 13.21
     handling of complaints, 1.54, 21.2, 21.4, 23.1, 23.5-23.9, 30.2, 30.10, 30.12, 30.13-30.15, 30.18-30.23, 30.27, 30.29
Fortune, Fr Sean, 1.79, 21.22
fostering of children, 28.5, 28.6
Framework Document (1996), 1.16, 1.89, 1.101, 1.111, 2.2, 3.39, 5.13, 7.1-7.57, 10.20, 13.48, 23.7, 28.126, 30.13, 31.14, 32.44, 40.12, 41.43
     education/formation of priests, 10.21-10.28
     guidelines, 7.6, 58.24-58.26
     implementation by Archdiocese, 7.15-7.20, 13.20, 13.77, 31.15, 37.24, 43.25, 58.26-58.27
     reporting policy, 1.33, 5.14, 5.15, 7.7-7.8
     review and replacement, 7.53
     Rome's response to, 7.13-7.14
     status of, 3.41, 7.11-7.14, 13.49
     structures and procedures for dealing with allegations, 7.9-7.10
     support person, 58.24
     training days, 7.12
France, 43.2, 43.3, 43.9
Francis Street parish, 26.14

G
Gallagher, Fr Donal, 1.69, 22.1-22.31
     Commission's assessment, 22.27-22.31
Garda Commissioners, 1.92, 1.93, 5.2, 5.5, 13.5
Garda investigations, 1.52, 1.79, 1.92-1.96, 1.95, 2.17, 5.1-5.43
     analytical overview, 5.26
     Archdiocese, contact with, 1.92, 5.13-5.18
     documents, access to, 5.27-5.33
          discovery process, 2.20
          legal privilege, 5.30-5.31
          material considered, 5.32-5.34
     Dublin Metropolitan Region (DMR), 5.3
     DVSAIU, 5.10-5.12
     health authorities, referrals by, 5.21-5.23
     individual cases. see individual names in representative sample [in bold]
     misprision of felony investigation, 5.35-5.39, 29.52
     NBCI. see National Bureau of Criminal Investigation
     outcome of, 5.40-5.43
     post-2002, 5.25-5.43
     pre-2002, 5.24, 5.42
     procedure, 5.4-5.7
     PULSE recording, 5.8
     recording of complaints, 5.43
     reporting of complaints. see reporting of complaints
     sex abuse unit (Harcourt Square), 1.95, 35.41
     submission of file to DPP, 5.5-5.6
     vetting of candidates for priesthood, 10.10
     Woman and Child Unit, 5.9
Garland, Finbar (garda), 28.29, 28.30, 28.32, 28.53, 28.59
Garland, Philip, 3.55, 11.13, 14.3, 14.6, 43.19, 45.4, 48.28, 48.29, 55.13
Gay Byrne Show (RTE), 24.41
General Charities Fund, 8.22
Giraldus*, Fr, 45.1-45.22
     Commission's assessment, 45.20-45.22
Glasthule parish, 26.1, 26.3, 26.9, 26.13
Gleeson, Fr Paddy, 7.17, 35.35, 35.40, 35.41, 42.14, 43.9, 43.12, 43.13
Glendalough, Co. Wicklow, 35.1, 35.15, 35.21, 35.56, 35.60
Glennon, Msgr Richard (chancellor, 1945-1955), 1.89, 11.13
     investigation of complaints, 17.5-17.6, 20.38, 21.2, 21.4, 32.5
Granada Institute, Dublin, 1.70, 1.73, 11.16
     treatment and assessments, 12.22, 13.59, 13.62, 17.34, 17.35, 21.9-21.16, 21.29, 24.40, 24.67, 27.8, 27.13, 27.17, 27.27, 27.31, 29.45, 29.49, 30.15-30.17, 30.18, 31.9, 31.14, 32.9, 32.11, 32.14, 32.31, 32.33, 32.36, 32.40, 33.19, 33.29-33.32, 34.17, 35.3, 35.23, 35.26, 37.44-37.47, 39.22-39.30, 39.39, 39.40, 40.20, 40.24, 40.30, 41.3, 42.16 42.18, 43.7, 43.16-43.17, 45.9, 45.11, 45.13, 46.8-46.9, 48.24, 48.25, 51.2
Grand Rapids, Michigan (USA), 20.135
The Grange orphanage, Kill O' The Grange, 28.8, 28.18-28.24, 28.25, 28.108
Green Book. see Framework Document (1996)
An Grianán, 28.22, 28.25-28.26
grooming, 4.2, 16.3, 16.12, 40.20
Guidelines for the Identification and Management of Non-Accidental Injury to Children (1980), 6.70
guidelines on child sexual abuse, 42.20
     church authorities, 7.6, 7.26-7.43, 7.53-7.55. see also canon law; Framework Document
     health authorities, 5.21-5.22, 6.4, 6.68-6.76, 29.34. see also Children First guidelines
     reporting to civil authorities. see reporting of complaints
Guido*, Fr, 1.12, 11.11, 51.1-51.14
     Commission's assessment, 51.14

H
Halston Street, 12.4
Harold's Cross parish, 52.3, 52.4, 52.7, 52.15, 52.19, 52.20, 52.21
Harrington Street parish, 12.4
Health Acts, 6.26, 6.33, 6.42
health authorities, 1.97-1.98, 6.1-6.76. see also health boards; HSE
     child protection role, 6.7, 6.9, 6.27-6.32, 6.37-6.51. see also child protection services (health authorities)
          statutory duties (1991 Act), 6.21-6.32
     community care programme, 6.42-6.57
     'fit person' procedure, 6.9, 6.17, 6.18
     general powers and duties, 1.97, 1.99
     guidelines on child sex abuse, 5.21-5.22, 6.68-6.76, 29.34
     handling of child abuse complaints, 1.98, 6.1-6.6, 6.27-6.32, 6.55-6.57
          individual cases. see under names of individuals [in bold]
     legislation relating to, 6.10-6.26
     reporting of complaints to, 5.22-5.23
     structural changes, 6.5, 6.33-6.36
health boards, 1.97, 1.98, 6.9. see also health authorities; individual health boards
     child protection role, 6.9, 6.21-6.31, 6.42-6.50. see also child protection services
     establishment, 6.33, 6.42
     handling of complaints, 29.28
     records, keeping of, 6.29
     residential institutions, role in relation to, 6.19-6.20
     structural changes, 6.33-6.36
Health Services Research Centre (RCSI), 7.46-7.47
hearings of Commission, 2.14-2.16
High Street parish, 52.3, 52.9, 52.11, 52.17, 52.19, 52.21
Higher Education and Training Awards Council (HETAC), 10.2
Holy Cross College, Dublin. see Clonliffe College
Holy Ghost Fathers, 35.2
Holy See. see Rome/Vatican
homosexuality, 21.2, 21.3, 21.10, 28.119, 33.35, 49.1, 51.2
     apostolate to gay community, 21.2, 21.3, 21.31
     candidates for priesthood, and, 10.32, 10.34, 10.37-10.38
Horatio*, Fr, 1.64, 1.79, 21.1-21.33
     Commission's assessment, 21.31-21.33
hospital chaplains, 24.1
Hospitaller Order of St John of God. see St John of God Order
Houlihan, Brendan, 10.11
Howth District Court, 28.56
Howth parish, 41.8, 41.34
HSE (Health Service Executive), 2.10, 2.17, 11.5, 18.6, 43.13, 45.5, 45.7, 45.13-45.17
     audit, 7.51
     clerical child sex abuse, and, 1.97, 1.98, 5.21, 6.27
     Commission's dealings with, 2.19, 6.6, 6.59-6.67, 45.22
     documentation held by, 6.6
          discovery process, 2.19, 6.60-6.66
          filing system, 2.19, 6.60
          need for collation and maintenance of, 6.29-6.30
          provision to Commission, 45.22
     duty to communicate information, 6.31-6.32
     establishment (2005), 6.5, 6.35
     inter agency review committee, 5.19
     local health offices (LHOs), 6.51
     powers and functions, 6.26, 6.35
Hugo*, Fr, 1.54, 23.1-23.15
     Commission's assessment, 23.13-23.15
Hurley, Mark (bishop of Santa Rosa), 20.74, 20.75, 20.78-20.81, 20.84, 20.124
Hussey, Judge Gillian, 7.50

I
Ignatio*, Fr, 53.1-53.16
imputability, concept of, 4.56-4.61, 4.93
industrial and reformatory schools. see residential institutions
institutional care. see residential institutions
institutional immunity, 1.113
insurance, 1.20, 1.21, 3.38, 8.3, 9.1-9.39, 20.100
     agreements with Church & General
          first 'special policy,' 9.6-9.12, 9.36
          lump sum agreement, 9.22-9.23
          reassessment, 9.17-9.21
          re-opening of negotiations, 9.24-9.32
          second agreement, 9.30-9.32
Commission's assessment, 9.35-9.39
compensation claims, receipt of, 9.24
cover for liability arising from 1996, 9.33-9.34
information known to the Archdiocese, 9.11
insurers, 9.1
need for insurance cover, 9.2-9.5
parish protection policies, 9.13-9.16
policy limits, 9.12
     exclusion of liability, 9.9, 9.14, 9.17
premiums, 9.12
requirements on Archbishop, 9.7
Interpol, 45.10
investigation of complaints
     Church, by. see canon law; Church authorities; Dublin Archdiocese
     individual cases in representative sample. see individual names [in bold]
     State, by. see Garda investigations
Ioannes*, Fr, 1.38, 1.78, 1.89, 17.1-17.46, 32.5, 32.6
     Commission's assessment, 17.42-17.46
Irish Catholic Bishops' Conference, 3.38-3.43, 7.2
     Advisory Committee on Child Sexual Abuse, 3.38, 3.39, 5.13, 7.2-7.5
     child protection office, 7.49, 10.10
     Committee on child abuse, 7.45
     independent audit, 7.50-7.51
     initiatives by, 7.44-7.57. see also Framework Document (1996)
     national training initiative, 7.52
     powers of, 3.40
     research into child abuse, 7.46-7.48
Irish Catholic Property Insurance Company Ltd, 9.1
Irish College (Rome), 10.1, 10.32, 10.33
Irish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children (ISPCC), 6.39

J
Jacobus*, Fr, 50.1-50.14
     Commission's assessment, 50.14
Japan, 16.1, 16.2, 16.7-16.11
Jemez Springs (New Mexico), 20.55-20.62, 20.67-20.72, 20.129, 20.140, 39.6, 39.11, 39.20, 39.22, 39.36
John Paul II, Pope, 3.47
     dismissal of Fr Jovito* (1996), 19.102-19.105
John XXIII, Pope, 4.9
Jovito*, Fr, 1.38, 1.42, 1.44, 1.77, 4.29, 4.66-4.68, 7.14, 19.1-19.128 [Note: "Fr Jovito" (Tony Walsh) is also discussed in: 1.26, 35.52, and 41.13]
     Commission's assessment, 19.123-19.128
judicial vicars, 24.27, 24.37

K
Kavanagh, James (auxiliary bishop, 1972-1998), 1.23, 1.47, 1.52, 1.89, 3.24, 21.2, 33.4
     awareness of clerical child sex abuse, 1.22
     Gardai, contacts with, 28.48-28.49, 28.52
     handling of complaints, 1.52, 16.25, 20.14-20.17, 20.33, 29.31
          Carney case, 28.6, 28.34, 28.39-28.41, 28.48-28.49, 28.52, 28.54, 28.56, 28.61, 28.63, 28.64, 28.70, 28.78, 28.81, 28.98, 28.106, 28.133, 28.141
Keenan, Dr Marie, 7.48, 10.37
Kelly, Fr Donal, 4.31
Kelly, Fr James, 20.44, 20.52, 28.87
Kennedy, David, 7.22, 7.23, 7.27, 7.41
Kennedy Report (1970), 6.8
Kerry (county), 41.16, 41.19
Kiernan, Sergeant (garda), 28.29, 28.30, 28.31, 28.52, 28.57, 28.59, 28.66
Kildare and Leighlin, diocese of, 3.13
Kill O' The Grange. see The Grange orphanage
Kilmore parish, 35.5-35.9, 35.41, 35.48
Kilquade parish, 26.4
Kiltegan Fathers. see St Patrick's Missionary Society, Kiltegan
Kinsella, Fr John, 38.1-38.17
     Commission's assessment, 38.16-38.17
Klaudius*, Fr, 40.1-40.31
     Commission's assessment, 40.34-40.36

L
Laffoy Commission, 7.45
laicisation, 7.33, 7.39, 15.8-15.10, 16.61, 18.5, 24.72, 28.120, 40.31, 41.42, 51.13
Lakelands children's home, Sandymount, 28.8
Lane O'Kelly, Dr, 28.84, 28.85, 28.87, 28.88
Laurentius*, Fr, 39.1-39.42
     Commission's assessment, 39.34-39.42
law. see canon law; child protection legislation
Law Reform Commission, 2.9
legal actions. see civil legal actions
legal challenge to discovery process, 2.33-2.35
legal costs, 2.42, 8.4, 8.30
legal privilege, 2.25-2.35, 5.30-5.31
legislation. see child protection legislation
limitation periods, in canon law, 4.62-4.64
Liveline (RTE), 5.27, 5.34, 12.37
Livingstone, Fr Benedict, 20.67, 20.140
local health offices (LHOs), 6.51
London, 41.8
Los Angeles diocese (USA), 20.84-20.85, 20.112
Lourdes pilgrimage. see Dublin Diocesan Pilgrimage to Lourdes

M
McCarthy, Fr Francis, 24.58, 28.2, 28.13, 28.39, 28.68, 28.118, 28.126, 41.1-41.43
     Commission's assessment, 41.43
McFeely, Anthony (bishop of Raphoe), 16.13, 16.72, 16.74
McGovern, Joe (Garda superintendent), 20.92-20.96
McGrady, Andrew, 1.14n
McGrath, Fr Aidan (judicial vicar), 4.19, 4.31
McMahon, Msgr James Ardle, 1.89, 11.13, 15.5, 16.25
     investigation of complaints, 24.18, 25.10, 28.37, 29.5
          case, and, 20.20-20.25, 20.178
McNamara, Kevin (Archbishop of Dublin, 1985-1987), 1.25, 1.36, 1.41, 4.21, 4.88, 9.4, 20.77, 20.99, 20.136
     awareness of clerical child sex abuse, 1.21
     handling of complaints, 3.22, 17.10, 20.79, 20.81-20.86, 20.125, 22.11, 24.27, 28.78, 28.79, 29.12, 29.14, 29.19, 29.21, 29.24, 29.54, 29.56
     insurance cover, and, 9.4, 9.6
McNamee, Fr James, 1.38, 1.66, 12.1-12.51
     Commission's assessment, 12.42-12.51
McQuaid, John Charles (Archbishop of Dublin, 1940-1972), 1.19, 1.36, 1.37, 1.56,
1.89, 1.92, 4.21, 26.3, 35.2, 57.1
     awareness of clerical child sex abuse, 1.21
     handling of complaints, 3.18, 12.6-12.8, 12.43, 13.5-13.11, 13.69-13.71, 15.3, 34.6
Madden, Andrew, 7.4, 8.3, 9.24, 24.4, 24.11, 24.15, 24.28, 24.33, 24.35, 24.38, 24.41, 24.44, 24.67, 58.16, 58.20
     compensation settlement. see under Payne, Fr Ivan
Magnus*, Fr, 1.12, 11.11, 49.1-49.7
     Commission's assessment, 49.6
Maguire, Fr Patrick, 1.22, 1.38, 1.69, 4.36, 16.1-16.75, 28.2, 28.43
     Commission's assessment, 16.70-16.75
Mahony, Dr (archbishop of Los Angeles), 20.84, 20.85
Malahide, Co. Dublin, 28.77
Mangan, Fr Cyril, 7.17, 20.166, 52.7, 52.10, 52.15
Marist Fathers, 1.64, 28.67, 28.69, 28.73, 28.75, 28.77
Marius*, Fr, 34.1-34.34
     Commission's assessment, 34.32-34.34
marriage tribunal. see Dublin Regional Marriage Tribunal
Martin, Diarmuid (Archbishop of Dublin, 2004-), 1.13, 1.79, 3.17, 3.48-3.49, 8.21, 12.40, 27.39, 43.20, 48.28, 54.6
     co-operation with Commission, 1.87
     education/formation of priests, 10.33
     handling of complaints, 21.22, 21.25, 21.27, 21.29, 28.128, 51.13
     legal privilege issue, and, 2.26-2.29, 5.31
     publication of settlements, 1.112
     reporting of complaints, 21.27
Maynooth College. see St Patrick's College, Maynooth
     medical experts, 24.22. see also psychiatric/psychological assessment; individual
practitioners
Medjugorje, 26.28
Memorandum on Non-Accidental Injury to Children (1977), 6.69
mental reservation, 58.19-58.21
metropolitan bishop, office of, 3.12
Midland Health Board, 6.33
Milltown, 28.67
Milltown Institute of Theology and Philosophy, 10.2
Minister for Health, 6.10, 6.11
Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform, 5.2, 7.50
misprision of felony investigation, 5.35-5.39, 29.52
monitoring of clerical offenders, 1.75, 1.82-1.85, 7.38, 7.40, 12.21, 13.57, 13.59, 16.67, 20.44-20.50, 20.45, 20.80, 20.83, 21.29, 24.61-24.62, 29.43-29.49, 34.17, 34.20, 34.44, 35.37, 37.3, 37.25-37.26, 48.28, 48.29
Moone abbey, 35.19, 35.20-35.22
Moore, Fr Harry, 1.65, 26.1-26.42
     Commission's assessment, 26.36-26.42
Moriarty, James (auxiliary bishop, 1991-2002), 11.13, 13.14-13.15, 13.43-13.44
Morning Ireland (RTE), 24.76
Mourne Road parish, 24.1
Murphy (Garda Inspector), 28.30, 28.52, 28.57, 28.66
Murray, Donal (auxiliary bishop, 1985-1996), 1.47, 1.53, 1.58, 1.65, 1.89, 3.22, 11.13, 21.6, 26.34
     awareness of clerical child sex abuse, 1.22
     handling of complaints, 1.53, 12.22-12.25, 12.49, 21.23-21.24, 26.19, 29.4-29.12, 29.15, 29.53, 29.54, 29.56, 31.5, 31.12, 33.6-33.13, 33.18, 33.44

N
National Board for Safeguarding Children, 7.55
National Bureau of Criminal Investigation (NBCI), 5.6, 5.10, 5.32, 47.3, 52.11
National Child Protection Office (Maynooth), 3.55, 10.10
National Council for Educational Awards, 10.2
National Marriage Appeal Tribunal, 24.29
National Rehabilitation Hospital, Dun Laoghaire, 1.51, 1.66, 35.26, 35.27, 35.35
Naughton Fr Thomas, 1.53, 1.66, 1.89, 6.2, 8.31, 29.1-29.63, 52.2, 58.17
     Commission's assessment 29.53-29.63
New Mexico (USA), 11.15. see also Jemez Springs
Noonan, Fr Mark, 22.14, 22.24
Norbertine Order, 7.3
Norman, Fr James, 13.19, 13.48, 13.55, 13.77, 58.21
Northern Area Health Board, 13.65

O
Ó Ceallaigh, Fiachra (auxiliary bishop, 1994-), 11.13, 27.14, 27.21, 42.8, 42.21
O'Connor, Maurice (garda chief superintendent), 28.39, 28.40, 28.48-28.49, 28.51, 28.54
O'Donnell, Fr Desmond, 10.36
O'Mahony, Dermot (auxiliary bishop, 1975-1996), 1.23, 1.42, 1.47, 1.48-1.51, 1.67, 3.24, 11.13, 18.3
     awareness of clerical child sex abuse, 1.22
     confidential documents, shredding of, 15.17-15.18
     handling of complaints, 1.49-1.51, 15.8, 15.10, 15.13, 15.14, 15.16-15.19, 15.21,17.7-17.9, 18.3-18.4, 18.7, 21.3, 21.5, 21.9, 23.9, 23.10, 24.21, 28.6, 28.104, 31.8, 35.26, 35.30-35.32, 35.57, 35.61, 36.6-36.8, 36.13
          Payne case, 24.6-24.15, 24.18, 24.23, 24.25, 24.27, 24.28, 24.30, 24.33, 24.43, 24.44, 24.54, 24.62, 24.65, 24.68, 24.79, 24.80
          Septimus case, 27.3-27.8, 27.10, 27.13, 27.37-27.38, 27.47-27.48
     pastoral care of priests, responsibility for, 24.6, 24.8
Opus Dei, 3.32
oral evidence, 2.15
Orange diocese (USA), 20.112, 20.113-20.114
O'Regan, Msgr John, 11.13, 12.12-12.17, 12.43-12.45
orphanages, 28.11-28.26. see also residential institutions
Ó Saorai, Fr (Ayrfield parish)
     Carney case, and, 28.30, 28.31, 28.33, 28.36, 28.38, 28.40-28.41, 28.44, 28.50, 28.140
Ossory, diocese of, 3.13, 30.1, 30.2, 30.9, 30.13, 30.18, 30.19, 30.27
Our Children Our Church (2005), 3.41, 5.18, 5.20, 7.52, 7.53, 10.29
     education/formation of priests, 10.31
Our Duty to Care (2002), 6.75
Our Lady's Hospital for Sick Children, Crumlin, 2.10, 13.2, 13.4-13.22, 13.5
     child sex abuse assessment unit, 6.54, 6.56
     complaints of abuse in, 24.1, 24.3, 24.44, 24.45, 24.47, 24.48, 24.50-24.51

P
paedophilia, 1.76, 17.15, 17.32, 20.67, 20.83, 28.119, 28.122, 39.22
     imputability in canon law, and, 4.59-4.61, 4.93
Palmerstown parish, 20.6, 20.63
Papal Nuncio, 2.24, 3.50
parents of victims
     concerns of, 4.2
     effects on, 58.10-58.13
Pastoral Services Fund, 8.12
Paul VI, Pope, 4.10
Payne, Fr Ivan, 1.41, 1.44, 1.50, 4.29, 4.36, 7.4, 8.3, 17.35, 24.1-24.83, 41.36
     Commission's assessment, 24.79-24.83
712
penal provisions in church law. see canon law; canonical trials
personal prelatures, 3.32
Phibsborough. see St Peter's parish
Phineas*, Fr, 14.1-14.8
Poor of Dublin Fund, 8.26, 24.73
Pope, the, 3.44, 3.45
Portmarnock, 47.1
Portmarnock Community Centre, 28.74, 28.75
Portmarnock Leisure Centre, 28.87
Post Graduate Fund, 8.27-8.29
prescription, period of, 4.62-4.64
priests. see also College of Consultors; Council of Priests
     appointment of, 1.56
     assignment to parishes, 1.47
     awareness of clerical child sex abuse, 1.24
     children, sexual abuse of. see clerical child sex offenders
     duty of obedience, 3.28
     formation. see education/formation of priests
     income, 8.13-8.15
     parish priests and curates, 3.26-3.33
     personal prelatures, 3.32
     religious orders, from, 3.31-3.33
     representative sample. see representative sample
     supports for, 8.13-8.31
     termination payments, 8.16-8.17
Prime Time (RTÉ), 5.25, 5.27, 5.34, 13.63-13.66, 13.83. see also Cardinal Secrets
Probation Act, 28.59
Probation and Welfare Service, 1.83, 16.66, 16.67
Pro-Cathedral, Dublin, 1.78, 20.3-20.25, 20.4-20.8, 20.15-20.17
procedural rules (Vatican), 4.17-4.29. see also Crimen Solicitationis; Sacramentorum Sanctitatis Tutela (2001)
Propaganda College (Rome), 10.1
prosecution of offences. see Director of Public Prosecutions
pseudonyms, 7.27
psychiatric/psychological assessment, 1.70-1.72, 11.14. see also treatment for clerical offenders
     candidates for priesthood, 10.8-10.9, 10.19, 10.21, 10.34
     representative sample, priests in. see individual names [in bold]
Public Assistance Act 1939, 6.39
PULSE, 5.8

Q
Q (M) v Robert Gleeson and others, 6.31
Quinton*, Fr, 33.1-33.43
     Commission's assessment, 33.41-33.45

R
Raheny, 28.77
Rape Crisis Centre, 28.78, 41.6
Raphoe, diocese of, 16.12-16.17, 16.26, 16.44
Ratzinger, Cardinal Joseph (later Pope Benedict XVI), 3.45, 27.36
Read, Msgr Gordon, 4.7, 4.19
recidivism, 1.44, 1.73
recording of cases, 1.89, 4.37
     Garda, by, 5.43
     Garda PULSE system, 5.8
     health authorities, by, 1.98
reformatory schools. see residential institutions
rehabilitation, 1.75, 1.81. see also treatment for clerical offenders
Reidy, Dr Maurice, 20.18-20.20
religious orders, 2.10, 3.31-3.33, 29.1, 32.1, 33.1, 37.1, 39.1, 40.1, 44.2, 45.1, 46.1,
50.1, 53.1, 57.1. see also St Joseph's orphanage; individual orders
     Archdiocese, communications with, 1.69
     awareness of clerical child sex abuse, 1.22
     co-operation with Commission, 1.87-1.89
     discovery of documents, 2.36
     monitoring of clerical offenders, 1.84
     orphanages, 28.11-28.26
removal of faculties. see canonical precepts
Report of the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse. see Ryan Report
reporting of complaints, 1.33, 1.36, 1.96, 1.111, 18.6, 20.4, 20.33, 20.89, 21.7-21.8,
21.27, 26.24-26.25, 27.12, 30.28, 31.9, 32.40, 34.19, 34.24, 36.9, 37.24, 40.18,
40.34, 41.6, 41.26, 41.34, 41.43, 43.12, 45.5, 50.6, 51.8, 51.9, 53.7, 55.5, 58.22
     Church guidelines, 5.14-5.18, 7.7-7.8
     confidentiality issues, 7.8
     Department of Health guidelines, 5.21, 6.71, 6.72
     failure to report, 1.32
     health boards, 5.22-5.23
representative sample, 1.3, 1.8, 1.10, 1.109, 2.2
     gender ratio of victims, 11.12
     investigation by Commission, 2.37. see also individual names [in bold]
     number of complaints, 1.8-1.12, 11.9
     priests, 11.7-11.8
     selection of sample, 11.1-11.6
research into child abuse, 7.46-7.48
Residential Institutions Redress Board, 24.3, 28.127
residential institutions, 6.8, 6.19, 6.20, 28.8-28.26, 39.10, 41.9-41.11, 41.23-41.24, 41.29-41.32, 41.33, 44.2-44.4, 45.2
     health boards, role of, 6.20
     visits from Clonliffe students, 28.8, 28.13, 41.9-41.11
restorative justice, 58.28
return to ministry, 1.73-1.75, 20.43
     advisory panel guidelines in relation to, 7.32-7.43
     conditions for, 7.33-7.34
     individual cases, 15.12-15.15, 15.20
     monitoring and supervision, 7.38. see also monitoring of clerical offenders
     practical implications, 7.36
     risk assessment, 7.34-7.35
Reynolds, Fr Noel, 1.51, 1.66, 30.24, 35.1-35.64
     Commission's assessment, 35.56-35.64
Ricardus*, Fr, 1.12, 11.11, 55.1-55.18
     Commission's assessment, 55.17-55.18
Ringsend garda station, 29.34
Ringsend parish, 26.4, 29.12, 29.26-29.33, 29.36, 29.55, 29.58, 29.61
Rolestown parish, 12.4
Roman Rota, 3.45, 16.64, 16.73
Rome/Vatican. see also Papal Nuncio
     appeals to,
     awareness of clerical sex abuse, 1.18
     Curia, 3.35n, 10.34
     documents held by, 2.23-2.24
     Dublin Archdiocese, and, 3.44-3.49
     Framework Document (1996), and, 3.41, 7.13-7.14
     rules for dealing with clerical sex abuse, 4.17-4.64. see also under canon law
Rossetti, Fr, 35.19
Rotunda Hospital, Dublin, 20.89
Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, 7.46
RTÉ, 12.21, 17.36, 24.41, 24.76, 38.3. see also Liveline; Morning Ireland; Prime
Time
Rufus*, Fr, 52.1-52.24
     Commission's assessment, 52.23-52.24
Rundle, Mervyn, 29.13-29.21, 29.39, 29.40, 29.52, 29.62
Ryan, Dermot (Archbishop of Dublin, 1972-1984), 1.20, 1.23, 1.25, 1.36, 1.38, 1.41, 1.49, 1.50, 1.56, 1.64, 3.24, 4.21, 4.36, 4.88, 20.77, 24.6, 24.8, 25.7, 27.3, 27.37, 27.48, 29.14, 35.6, 57.1
     awareness of clerical child sex abuse, 1.21
     handling of complaints, 3.19-3.21, 12.10, 12.12, 12.18, 12.46-12.48, 15.5, 16.25, 16.27, 16.28, 16.72, 17.8-17.9, 18.4, 21.3, 21.31, 23.6, 23.8, 23.10, 29.6, 35.12-35.14
          Carney case, 28.4, 28.5, 28.6, 28.37, 28.46, 28.48, 28.63-28.65, 28.70, 28.71, 28.74-28.76
          Moore case, 26.1-26.2, 26.5, 26.8, 26.10, 26.11-26.12, 26.36-26.40
          Payne case, 24.5, 24.7, 24.9, 24.14, 24.27, 24.79
Ryan Commission, 1.6, 1.7, 7.45
Ryan Report, 1.5-1.7, 6.19

S
Sacramento diocese (California), 1.49, 15.12, 15.13 – 15.16, 15.21, 20.115, 20.117, 20.118, 20.124-20.126, 20.137, 20.160
Sacramentorum Sanctitatis Tutela (2001), 3.49, 4.29
Saggart parish, 35.15
St John of God Hospital, Dublin, 26.5, 26.38, 27.4, 27.10
St John of God Order (Hospitallers), 11.14, 11.16, 17.15, 17.26, 28.119, 33.5, 33.18, 33.19. see also Quinton*, Fr; St John of God Hospital
St Joseph's orphanage, Tivoli Road, 28.8, 28.11-28.17, 28.25, 28.91, 28.92, 28.96, 28.98, 28.126, 41.9, 41.10, 41.23, 41.33
St Laurence O'Toole Trust, 3.6
St Malachy's College, Belfast, 10.32
St Mary's School for the Deaf, 22.6-22.12, 22.20
St Nicholas of Myra parish. see Dunlavin parish
St Patrick's College, Maynooth, 7.52, 10.1
     education/formation of priests, 10.32, 10.33, 10.36-10.38
St Patrick's Hospital, Dublin, 20.151, 28.60, 28.61, 28.65, 28.67, 28.68
St Patrick's Missionary Society, Kiltegan, 8.31, 29.1, 29.37, 29.43, 29.60. see also Naughton, Fr Thomas
St Peter's parish, Phibsborough, 22.1, 22.4, 22.10-22.12, 22.15, 22.19
St Vincent's Hospital, Dublin, 20.24, 24.11
St Vincent's industrial school, Drogheda, 28.8, 28.10, 41.9
San Diego diocese (USA), 17.11-17.12, 17.36
Santa Fe archdiocese (USA), 20.62, 20.72
Santa Rosa diocese (USA), 20.74-20.81, 20.84, 20.124
scandal, avoidance of, 1.15, 1.32, 20.103, 20.104
school chaplains, 42.11-42.12
Scicluna, Charles J, 1.18n
Scotland Yard, 13.5
Seattle diocese (USA), 17.13-17.14
secrecy, requirement of. see confidentiality/secrecy
secret archive, 3.35, 4.88, 24.29, 34.8, 52.17
seminaries, 10.1, 10.32. see also education/formation of priests
Septimus*, Fr, 1.38, 27.1-27.48
     Commission's assessment, 27.46-27.48
Sergius*, Fr, 42.1-42.23
     Commission's assessment, 42.20-42.23
Servants of the Paraclete, 11.14, 11.15, 20.34, 20.35
     treatment centres. see Jemez Springs (New Mexico); Stroud (England)
settlements with victims, 1.112, 9.24, 12.29, 13.68, 16.69, 17.20, 17.25, 23.33, 36.11, 38.12, 52.22
Sex Offenders Act 2001, 1.83, 26.33, 32.38, 38.14
Sexual Abuse in the Catholic Church (2003), 1.18n
Sheehy, Msgr Gerard (chancellor, 1965-1975), 1.23, 1.26, 1.62, 3.24, 4.21, 4.31, 4.36, 11.13
     awareness of clerical child sex abuse, 1.22
     handling of complaints, 20.65, 24.5, 30.9-30.10, 30.12, 30.20, 30.21, 30.26, 30.27, 41.35-41.36
          Payne case, 24.27, 24.37, 24.47, 24.53, 24.58-24.59, 24.81, 41.36
Sisters of Our Lady of Charity. see The Grange orphanage; An Grianán
Smyth, Fr Brendan, 1.19, 7.3, 12.22, 24.37, 37.2
social work service (health authorities), 6.38, 6.39, 6.40-6.41, 6.42, 6.43
     child sex abuse complaints, handling of, 6.52-6.57
     staff shortages, 6.57-6.58
Society of St Columban. see Columban Fathers
South Eastern Health Board (SEHB), 6.33
Stardust fire, 20.127, 20.129
State authorities, 1.92-1.101. see also Garda investigations; health authorities; health boards; HSE
     child protection, responsibility for, 1.99-1.100, 1.113
     communications with Church authorities, 1.101
     cover-up, facilitation of, 1.113
Stella Maris Football Club, 12.5-12.9
Stenson, Msgr Alex (chancellor, 1981-1997), 1.60, 1.89, 3.37, 4.21, 4.22, 4.30, 4.35, 4.41, 4.47, 4.48, 4.88, 7.17, 7.18, 9.16, 10.11, 11.13, 12.22, 25.9
     awareness of clerical child sex abuse, 1.22
     handling of complaints, 1.61, 12.22, 12.31, 16.25, 16.29, 16.44, 17.12, 17.14, 17.15-17.16, 17.22-17.23, 17.34, 17.45, 22.23, 23.9-23.11, 24.4-24.5, 24.7, 26.18, 29.14-29.16, 29.19-29.22, 29.36, 29.59, 32.6, 33.6, 33.14, 33.19- 33.22, 33.25-33.26, 34.1-34.4, 34.8-34.11, 34.15, 34.20, 35.1, 35.16-35.22, 35.56, 35.57, 37.6, 37.9-37.10, 38.4, 38.8-38.9, 38.16, 41.21-41.24, 41.34, 42.5
          Carney case, 28.37, 28.44-28.47, 28.68, 28.74-28.75, 28.78-28.115 passim, 28.123, 28.126, 28.131, 28.135, 29.5
          Edmondus* case, 13.17-13.18, 13.22-13.28, 13.32-13.33, 13.39-13.46, 13.51, 13.55, 13.75-13.76
          Jovito* case, 19.13-19.20, 19.23, 19.25-19.36, 19.43, 19.48, 19.50-19.51, 19.56-19.76, 19.79, 19.83-19.85, 19.90-19.92, 19.99-19.100
Payne case, 24.37, 24.43, 24.45, 24.49, 24.51, 24.57, 24.71
Septimus* case, 27.9-27.15, 27.26-27.29
Stewardship Trust, 8.3, 8.4, 8.5-8.6, 8.23
Dublin Archdiocese, interaction with, 8.7-8.10
objects of, 8.5
Stockton diocese (USA), 20.152, 20.153, 20.155
Stroud (England) treatment centre, 1.20, 11.15, 16.14, 16.47, 20.33-20.42, 20.47-20.49, 20.140, 20.143, 22.13-22.18, 22.25, 26.10, 28.45, 28.72, 28.78, 28.79, 28.81, 28.119, 29.23-29.25, 29.29, 29.36, 37.13-37.14, 37.17, 37.25, 37.30, 38.1, 51.7, 51.10
suffragen bishops, 3.13, 3.14
support services, 1.16
support structures for victims, 1.111
Sutton Golf Club, 28.54, 28.56
Sutton parish, 1.66, 24.2, 24.14, 24.26, 24.28, 24.40, 24.46, 24.48-24.49, 24.52
Suttonians Rugby Club, 28.56

T
Task Force on Child Care Services, 6.10-6.13
Terentius*, Fr, 37.1-37.53
     Commission's assessment, 37.49-37.53
therapy. see treatment for clerical offenders
training in child protection, 7.52
Tralee, Co. Kerry, 20.6, 41.19
treatment for clerical offenders, 1.70-1.72, 1.86, 7.32, 11.14-11.16
     costs, 8.31, 20.58
     counselling, 1.86
     drug therapy, 20.67-20.72, 20.151
     individual cases. see under names in representative sample [in bold]
     psychiatric treatment, 1.70-1.72
     treatment centres, 11.14-11.16. see also Granada Institute (Dublin); Jemez Springs (New Mexico); Stroud (England)
Trinity College Dublin, 5.10
Trust in Care (2005), 6.76
Tuam, diocese of, 35.13, 35.14, 35.48
Tyrus*, Fr, 18.1-18.7
     Commission's assessment, 18.7

U
United Kingdom, 16.1, 16.2, 16.11, 16.17, 16.30-16.33. see also Stroud
University College Dublin, 3.24, 7.48, 10.2, 11.4, 24.1, 24.11
USA, 17.9, 17.26, 17.30, 20.56, 20.68
     treatment centres. see Jemez Springs (New Mexico)

V
Valleymount parish, 1.89, 29.1, 29.4-29.12, 29.53, 29.56, 58.17
Vatican. see Rome/Vatican
Vatican II (1961-65), 4.9, 4.10, 4.13
vicarious liability, 9.3
vicars forane (deans), 3.25
vicars general, 3.9, 3.10, 3.17
Vice Officialis, 24.27
victims. see complainants
Vidal*, Fr, 1.49, 15.1-15.20
     Commission's assessment, 15.19
Vincentian Order, 22.1, 22.14, 22.20. see also Gallagher, Fr Donal

W
Walkinstown, 28.4
Walsh, Eamonn (auxiliary bishop, 1990-), 4.50, 7.22, 10.11, 11.13, 35.32, 41.34
     committee on child abuse, chairmanship of, 7.45
     handling of complaints, 24.27, 43.5
Walsh, Noel (psychiatrist), 20.24-20.25, 30.6-30.7
     Payne case, 24.11-24.14, 24.16-24.25, 24.30, 24.31, 24.36, 24.80
Walsh, Dr Patrick, 12.22, 17.15, 17.18, 17.23, 17.24, 26.15, 26.20, 26.22, 26.23, 26.27, 27.13, 27.17, 27.18, 33.5, 33.8-33.13, 33.18, 33.19, 33.22, 33.23, 33.36, 33.40, 33.44, 35.3-35.4, 35.22, 35.24-35.25, 35.26, 35.30, 35.32, 35.34
     Fr Horatio case, 21.11-21.21, 21.26
West Indies, 29.1, 29.41
Western Australia Task Force on Child Sexual Abuse, 2.9n
Westland Row parish, 1.83
Whitehall garda station, 28.39, 28.49
Wicklow (county), 13.36, 13.54, 13.82-13.83 see also Enniskerry;Glendalough
William Street North (parish), 1.78
Williams, Desmond (auxiliary bishop, 1984-1993), 8.1, 28.90, 28.97
     handling of complaints, 30.5, 30.6, 30.10
Wilson, Msgr John, 8.1, 8.2, 20.75, 28.38, 28.39, 28.60, 28.62, 28.123, 28.124
Woman and Child Unit (Garda), 5.9
Woods, Dr Michael, TD, 28.6
Would You Believe (RTE), 13.61