But both the Iwerne Trust, the Christian group that Mr Smyth chaired, and Winchester College, the school attended by some of his alleged victims, did not report the claims to police.
The part-time judge then moved to Zimbabwe, where he founded a series of summer camps at which it is alleged he again abused young men.
In 1997 he was charged with culpable homicide after a boy was found naked in the swimming pool of one of his camps, but the prosecution later collapsed.
It has now emerged that a number of senior figures at high-profile evangelical organisations were told of the claims but did not alert the authorities.
David Fletcher, a Iwerne trustee who oversaw an investigation into the alleged assaults, said he told the Church Society, a powerful voice on the evangelical wing of the Church of England, about the claims in 1982.