N.Y. church members beat teen to death, injured brother while trying to get them to ‘confess sins’: cops

By Corky Siemaszko
New York Daily News
October 14, 2015

http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/nyc-crime/teen-beaten-death-insiden-y-church-parents-charged-article-1.2397038

Bruce Leornard (l.) and Deborah Leonard (c.) enter the courtroom of before their the arraignment on Tuesday in New Hartford, N.Y. Photo by Mark DiOrio

From top left, Deborah Leonard, Bruce Leonard and Linda Morey. From bottom left, Joseph Irwin, Sarah Ferguson and David Morey. The Leonards of Clayville, N.Y., were charged with first-degree manslaughter in the beating death of their 19-year-old son.

Determined to get two brothers to “confess their sins,” members of a secretive upstate New York church beat one of the teenagers to death and badly brutalized the other, police said Wednesday.

Among those now charged with killing Lucas Leonard, 19, and injuring his 17-year-old brother Christopher during a “counseling session” at the Word of Life Church, are his parents and a sister, officials said.

“During the counseling session, the session turned physical,” said Chief Michael Inserra of the police in New Hartford, outside Utica.

Over the course of several hours, the brothers were ordered to “confess to prior sins and ask for forgiveness,” the chief said. “We have not determined what this punishment was for.”

But, said Inserra, “We know there were fists and feet involved” in the punishment.

Inserra spoke a day after the victim’s parents, Bruce and Deborah Leonard, were charged with first-degree manslaughter, and police revealed their sons had been brutally beaten on their genitals, abdomens, backs and thighs. Christopher Leonard remains hospitalized and in serious condition, the chief said.

Also arrested was the victims’ 33-year-old sister, Sarah Ferguson, who along with three other church members was charged with second-degree assault.

Inserra said more members of the church, described by neighbors as a cult, are under investigation.

Meanwhile, seven children — four of them Ferguson’s — have been removed from the church by state child welfare workers, Inserra said.

The investigation was launched after Leonard’s parents showed up at a local hospital Monday with their badly beaten son, Inserra said.

Lucas died at the hospital and an autopsy revealed he had died of blunt-force trauma, the chief said. Within hours, a police SWAT team descended on the Leonards’ home in Clayville and the church, where they found his brother on the second floor after several hours of searching.

“He wasn’t in hiding,” said Inserra. “But family members weren’t making him available.”

Bruce Leonard, 65, and his 59-year-old wife, Deborah, both pleaded not guilty during their arraignment Monday and were dispatched to the Oneida County jail after they were unable to raise $100,000 bail.

The four other suspects — Ferguson, Joseph Irwin, 26, of Chadwicks, David Morey, 26, of Utica and Linda Morey, 54, also of Utica — were each ordered held on $50,000 bail.

The Leonards’ neighbors said the couple homeschooled their kids and made them read the Bible for two hours every day. They said the children weren’t allowed to have sleepovers and were barred from Halloween trick-or-treating.

Inserra declined to comment on reports that the church is a cult. But residents who live nearby told the Syracuse Post-Standard that members would rarely venture out in the daylight hours and those who did often were men wearing what they described as “long, black trench coats.”

They said they would hear strange chanting coming from the building as late as 3 a.m.

A Post-Standard reporter who ventured inside the building Tuesday found police tape across two bathrooms, one labeled “Adam” and the other “Eve.”

The reporter also said there was a framed message hanging on one wall that read, in part, “We have been commissioned through the written word of God to reach out to those who have not experienced the love of Jesus Christ in their lives. Through the systematic training up of saints.”