Newark Archbishop's Future Retirement Home Undergoing a $500k Addition
By Mark Mueller
The 4,500-square-foot home sits on 8.2 wooded acres in the hills of Hunterdon County. With five bedrooms, three full bathrooms, a three-car garage and a big outdoor pool, it’s valued at nearly $800,000, records show. But it’s not quite roomy enough for Newark Archbishop John J. Myers. Myers, who has used the Franklin Township house as a weekend residence since the archdiocese purchased it in 2002, is building a three-story, 3,000-square-foot addition in anticipation of his retirement in two years, The Star-Ledger found. He will then move in full-time, a spokesman for the archbishop said. The new wing, now just a wood frame, will include an indoor exercise pool, a hot tub, three fireplaces, a library and an elevator, among other amenities, according to blueprints and permits filed with the Franklin Township building department. The price tag, the records show, will be a minimum of a half million dollars, a figure that does not include architectural costs, furnishings and landscaping. Construction is progressing as Myers asks the 1.3 million Roman Catholics of the archdiocese to open their wallets for the "archbishop’s annual appeal," a fundraising effort that supports an array of initiatives, including religious education, the training of future priests and feeding the poor.
More significantly, it comes at a time when Pope Francis has made profligate church spending a target of his early tenure. Francis, who eschewed the papal palace for a modest guest apartment and who gave up a Mercedes in favor of a Ford, has criticized bishops for living "like princes" and has called for a "poor church for the poor." In a move that signaled his impatience on the matter, the pope suspended the bishop of Limburg, Germany, in October for spending $42 million to renovate his residence and other church buildings. The German press dubbed the free-spending cleric the "Bishop of Bling." "Archbishop Myers obviously is not paying any attention to the pope," said Charles Zech, who has studied bishops’ spending as faculty director of the Center for Church Management and Business Ethics at Villanova University’s business school. "The pope is calling on clergy to live a simpler lifestyle and to be in touch with their people," Zech said. "This is extreme, way beyond what you’d expect to happen. I can’t believe the parishioners of Newark are going to allow this to happen." One such parishioner, Joan Rubino, was furious when a reporter told her about the work on the Franklin Township home. Rubino, who has attended Holy Family Church in Nutley for four decades — and who regularly contributed to the archbishops’ appeal — called Myers a "hypocrite." "To ask people to make sacrifices and then to live in a sumptuous residence, it makes me very annoyed," said Rubino, 77. "Isn’t there a better use for this money? In plain English, I feel like people are getting screwed."
Myers’ spokesman, Jim Goodness, said the addition will have no impact on archdiocese finances, saying the cost will be largely borne by the sale of other church-owned properties. Donors also have contributed to the project, Goodness said. He declined to identify the properties to be sold or provide the amount of the private donations. "There are not expected to be any expenses that can not be met by other real estate transactions, and it will remain an asset of the archdiocese," Goodness said. "It is not a personal asset." Zech, the Villanova professor, challenged the idea that real estate sales should be used to upgrade Myers’ future full-time residence, saying the revenues should be used for the betterment of the archdiocese and its people, not the archbishop. "This is taking money out of the pockets of parishioners," he said. "Current revenue and past revenue at one point all came from parishioners. If he thinks he can sell property and use it for his own extravagant needs, it’s mind-boggling." According to guidelines issued by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, all dioceses must provide a residence for retired bishops. The guidelines don’t specify, however, what kind of residence is required.
The retired bishop of Trenton, John M. Smith, lives in a modest apartment at a retirement home for priests in Lawrenceville. Likewise, retired Newark Archbishop Peter Gerety has lived for many years at a priests’ residence in Rutherford. Before his death in 2012, retired Metuchen Bishop Edward T. Hughes lived at a diocese-owned "spirituality center" in Milford, said Erin Friedlander, a spokeswoman for the diocese. The current bishop, Paul Bootkoski, contributed a portion of his own savings toward the purchase of a future retirement home near Lake Mohawk in Sussex County, Friedlander said. The diocese picked up the remainder of the cost, she said, declining to provide the precise amount. The diocese closed on the home for $471,000 last year, property records show. It will revert to the diocese upon Bootkoski’s death, Friedlander said. A spokeswoman for the Diocese of Trenton and a spokesman for the Diocese of Paterson did not respond to questions about residences for the bishops. Earlier this year, Camden Bishop Dennis Sullivan came under fire after using diocese funds to buy a historic 7,000-square-foot home in Woodbury. The house, with eight bedrooms and six bathrooms, cost $500,000. A spokesman for the diocese said last month Sullivan would live at the house with at least two other priests and that it would be used to host diocese functions.
The Archdiocese of Newark bought the Hunterdon County home for $700,000 in 2002, about seven months after Myers was named archbishop. Since then, Myers has primarily used it on weekends, though he tends to spend more time there during the summer, Goodness said. The home, built in 1989, is assessed at $776,700, and taxes were $18,695 last year, records show. Both figures are likely to jump significantly once the addition is completed. Myers, who turns 73 in July, is required to submit his resignation at 75. He could, however, retire sooner because the pope appointed a co-archbishop, Bernard Hebda, in September. Goodness said the home’s expansion was required because Myers will continue his involvement in church activities during retirement and will need office space. Schematics submitted to Franklin Township in 2011, when the main house was retrofitted with an elevator, show the elevator shaft lies next to an "existing office" in the finished basement, but the document does not state the room’s size. The spokesman said he was unaware of an office in the main house. The addition will house a large first-floor study and a smaller, attached library. A bedroom and sitting room — matching the footprint of the first-floor layout — are planned for the second floor. The third floor will house a 28-foot by 28-foot gallery with sweeping views of the property. Plans call for a fireplace on each level. A single-story "wellness room" will connect the main house and the addition. There, the blueprints show, workers will install a hot tub and a 14-foot by 7-foot Endless Pool, a brand of exercise pool. The pool’s jets provide a current, allowing one to swim in place. Goodness said it was too soon to say if Myers would be provided a staff when he moves in full time. The Rev. Thomas Reese, a senior analyst for the National Catholic Reporter, said it’s important to remember that Myers, as a diocesan priest, has not taken a vow of poverty. Some diocesan priests inherit large sums of family money. Others supplement their modest salaries by writing books. The difficulty, particularly in the age of Francis, is one of perception, Reese said. "How is this going to go over with the people who put their $10 in the collection basket?" he asked. "How is it going to go over with the big donors who give millions to schools? What kind of message is this sending?"
|
.
Any original material on these pages is copyright © BishopAccountability.org 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.