BishopAccountability.org
	Protecting Children--From What? By Phil Lawler Catholic Culture January 14, 2011 http://www.catholicculture.org/commentary/otn.cfm?id=754 Father Joseph Waters, the rector of the cathedral is St. Petersburg, Florida, seems to have an unfortunate knack for exposing himself to criticism. But leaving aside past controversies, the latest round of criticism—coming from parents who are upset about what the priest might have said to their children during confessions—appears wholly unjustified, even dangerous. According to the unhappy parents, Father Waters asked questions about masturbation and pornography when he heard the confessions of middle-school students at the Cathedral School of St. Jude. Some parents say these questions endanger "the safety of our children." Father Waters is quite rightly refusing to reveal anything at all about what took place in the confessional, but he insists that he was fulfilling his duty as a confessor. The diocese supported him, expressing "the utmost confidence" in the priest. The parents remain unsatisfied. We don't know what happened, and it's certainly possible for a priest to ask inappropriate questions on those topics. But the facts, as presented by a local TV station, suggest a problem with the parents rather than the priest. Parents should always protect their children from harm-- including the harm done by sin. Insofar as the priest was seeking to protect children from sin, he and the parents should have been working together. Masturbation and the use of pornography are epidemic problems among American adolescents. If he raised these questions in a way that disturbed innocent students, then Father Waters deserved a rebuke. But if he feared that a young Catholics might be developing a habit of serious sin, he was right to press the question. One of the many devastating effects of the sex-abuse scandal is the tendency to raise the alarm whenever a priest mentions sexual matters, especially with children. But in a society that is steeped in sexual sin, good priests must raise those questions—especially when they are trying to form the consciences of impressionable young people. Many children of middle-school age are still quite innocent. But many others are not, and even the most innocent will soon face the full flood of sexual temptations. Magazine kiosks and cable TV will invite them to view pornography; sex-ed counselors will encourage them to masturbate. It would be tragic if parental pressure discouraged priests from leading young people away from all those temptations.
Any original material on these pages is copyright © BishopAccountability.org 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.