BishopAccountability.org
	A Rebuke for Schonborn, a Revival for Sodano By Phil Lawler Catholic Culture June 30, 2010 http://www.catholicculture.org/commentary/otn.cfm?id=670 The news stories have been flowing out of Rome in such a torrent this week, I am only now finding the time to comment on Monday’s remarkable report about the Pope’s meeting with Cardinal Schonborn. Never before, in more than 25 years of covering Catholic news, had I seen the Vatican administer a public rebuke to a cardinal. The facts that Cardinal Schonborn is one of the most prominent prelates in Europe, as well as a student, friend, and ally of the Pope, make the story all the more extraordinary. Cardinal Schonborn brought the problem upon himself, with his statements criticizing Cardinal Angelo Sodano. Criticism of a Vatican Secretary of State inevitably reflects on the Pope to whom he was responsible. By suggesting that Cardinal Sodano resisted efforts to address the sex-abuse scandal, Cardinal Schonborn was indirectly implying that Pope John Paul II was not sufficiently vigilant in controlling his top lieutenant. No doubt Cardinal Sodano made that point—probably quite forcefully and repeatedly, albeit quietly, and behind the scenes—in response to Cardinal Schonborn’s criticism. No one is more skillful than the former Secretary of State in handling the internal politics of the Vatican. In the weeks that have passed since Schonborn let slip those imprudent remarks, Sodano doubtless persuaded his allies, and ultimately the Pope, that the criticism could not stand unchallenged without compromising the legacy of John Paul II and perhaps even of Pope Benedict as well. So the Pope called Cardinal Schonborn on the carpet—it is significant the Cardinal Sodano joined in the conversation as well—and the Vatican issued a “clarification” of the Austrian cardinal’s remarks. Without explicitly addressing the content of Cardinal Schonborn’s criticisms, the Vatican statement released after the meeting rightly slapped the wrist of the Austrian prelate for creating the fuss. According to that Vatican statement, Cardinal Schonborn wanted to clarify his remarks. Yet the Austrian cardinal was not allowed to make his own apologies, to issue his own statement, to face questions from the press by himself. The Vatican was taking no chances with a prelate who had already committed a serious gaffe. The June 28 statement was released by the Vatican press office—which is controlled by the Secretariat of State, Cardinal Sodano’s old fiefdom. In that fateful May session with reporters in Vienna, Cardinal Schonborn was driving home a point that most veteran Vatican reporters already understand: that during the pontificate of John Paul II, Cardinal Sodano was often at odds with then-Cardinal Ratzinger over the handling of sex-abuse complaints. The future Pontiff was pressing to root out the corruption, while the Secretary of State was defending the status quo. By criticizing Sodano, the Austrian prelate obviously intended to defend the Pope, especially in his handling of sex-abuse complaints. The move backfired badly. Six weeks later the Pope has endorsed a strong statement of support to Cardinal Sodano. Nearly four years after he finally stepped down from his post as Secretary of State after 15 years in that powerful post, Cardinal Sodano proved that he still carries considerable weight at the Vatican. More weight, certainly, than the Archbishop of Vienna. More weight, perhaps, than he had before this storm arose.
Any original material on these pages is copyright © BishopAccountability.org 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.