BishopAccountability.org
	Group That Opposes Closings Seeks Oversight of Bishop By Michael O'Malley Plain Dealer September 24, 2009 http://www.cleveland.com/news/plaindealer/index.ssf?/base/cuyahoga/1253781031213220.xml&coll=2 A group protesting Cleveland Bishop Richard Lennon's plan to close 50 Catholic churches intends to file a complaint with the Vatican today, asking that another bishop be appointed to oversee Lennon's actions. Separately, at least three Cleveland churches received letters from the Vatican this week, saying their appeals of Lennon's orders to close are being reviewed. Some parishioners from the three churches - St. Peter, St. Patrick in West Park and St. Barbara - are members of the protest group Endangered Catholics, which is seeking the oversight of Lennon. The request for oversight is in accordance with church law but is rarely exercised, said Catholic activist Peter Borre of Boston, who will file the complaint in Rome on behalf of the Cleveland group. Borre, who has been fighting church closings nationwide, said the law allows for the appointment of a supervising bishop when the diocesan bishop is seen as incompetent. Endangered Catholics, which represents 14 parishes in the eight-county diocese, believes Lennon "has proceeded recklessly" in his downsizing plan. In its complaint to the Congregation of Bishops - a Vatican office equivalent to a human-resources department - the group says that Lennon closed viable parishes without explanation and at times acted against the recommendations of cluster committees, grass-roots groups he convened for advice. "Bishop Lennon's failures in our diocese are a clear and present danger to many thousands of Catholics who are strongly attached to the vibrant parishes which face imminent destruction for no valid reason," the complaint says. The complaint to Cardinal Giovanni Battista Re is to be filed along with 5,000 petition signatures from Cleveland-area Catholics and non-Catholics opposed to the church closings. Endangered Catholics member Nancy McGrath of Akron, a parishioner at St. Peter's in downtown Cleveland, said she sent a copy of the complaint to the bishop by overnight mail on Tuesday. Diocese spokesman Robert Tayek said Wednesday that the bishop had not received the complaint, but Tayek issued a statement from Lennon. "It is my prayer that these members of our diocese will take the time and exercise prayerful patience to better understand what our clustering and reconfiguration plan is designed to achieve," the bishop said, adding that the church will become "stronger and more vibrant." "I believe they will find that the process for reconfiguring the diocese . . . will be accomplished within the proper canonical procedures of the church." A Vatican body known as the Congregation for the Clergy determines whether church law was followed in the closing process. It was that body that sent the letters to the three churches this week, saying it needed more time to review the cases and extending the deadline for doing so to Dec. 9. It wasn't immediately clear whether the letters are an indication that the appeals would be accepted - halting the closings while a decision is made - or whether the panel just needed more time to decide whether to accept the appeals. Some heralded the letters as major victories. Others were more cautious. "This is a big deal," said Pat Singleton, who heads Endangered Catholics and is a member of St. Patrick's of West Park. Leah Gary, parish council chair at St. Peter's, said, "It's better than hearing nothing. It's good to know they're considering the matter." Reached in Rome on Wednesday, Borre - who is handling 15 other appeals to the Vatican, but not ones from Cleveland -said the Congregation for the Clergy is simply giving itself an extension because it has been flooded with appeals and needs time to go through them. "This is not at all unusual," he said. "It should not be seen as salvation at hand." The 14 parishes represented by Endangered Catholics are: St. Adalbert, St. Barbara, St. Emeric, St. Lawrence, St. Patrick (West Park), St. Peter, St. Wendelin, all in Cleveland; St. James in Lakewood; St. John the Baptist and Sacred Heart, both in Akron; St. Mary in Bedford; St. Stanislaus and St. Joseph, both in Lorain; and St. Margaret of Hungary in Orange. Contact: momalley@plaind.com, 216-999-4893.
Any original material on these pages is copyright © BishopAccountability.org 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.