BishopAccountability.org
	Stories Goes to Grave: Plouffe; Bishop Says Full Story of Abuse Allegations May Never Be Known By Carol Mulligan Sudbury Star January 28, 2008 http://www.thesudburystar.com/ArticleDisplay.aspx?e=879819 We will never know the full story behind claims of sexual abuse against Roman Catholic clergy and the people who make them, says Bishop Jean-Louis Plouffe. Plouffe isn't denying there have been instances of sexual abuse by priests in the Roman Catholic Diocese of Sault Ste. Marie, but they are hard to prove when the priests named in lawsuits are dead. "Let's put it this way: 'They've taken it to their grave,' " said Plouffe on Monday in a 55-minute interview with The Sudbury Star. Plouffe was responding to a news conference held hours earlier at which seven lawsuits against Roman Catholic dioceses and a religious order of priests were announced by Ledroit Beckett Litigation Lawyers of London, Ont. Six of the lawsuits were filed against the Diocese of Sault Ste. Marie and four of the five priests named in those suits are deceased. One, Gerald Roy, is in his early 70s and lives in Warren, east of Sudbury, said Plouffe. The bishop said Roy took early retirement after he served time in a federal penitentiary after he was sentenced in 2001 to 2 1/2 years for sexual abuse of four altar boys in the 1980s. "After coming back (from prison), Roy decided that he wanted to live as a hermit, a monk. He wanted to live a sort of monastic life and his ministry is now one of prayer," said Plouffe. Roy is allowed to celebrate mass "on his own, for himself. But he has not asked to be defrocked or dispensed of his priestly obligations "of celibacy and prayer for the church," said Plouffe. Roy, Father Don Holmes and Father Thomas O'Dell have all been convicted of sexual offences against children and are living on pensions which all priests pay into from the day they were ordained, said Plouffe. Plouffe said regular Sunday contributions from parishioners in the Diocese of Sault Ste. Marie do not support these priests. "Absolutely nothing. I look you in the eyes. Nothing, absolutely nothing," said Plouffe. Priests have vested rights in a pension plan "and it kicks in whenever it has to," he said. Priests, such as the three convicted, do not get the maximum pensions because they retired early. Priests who have been disgraced with criminal convictions can continue to say mass privately, but no longer receive appointments from the bishop. Once civil lawsuits are filed against the diocese for sexual misconducts by its priests, those cases must proceed through the legal system. Plouffe said his diocese is accepting responsibility for the alleged sexual misconduct of some of its priests, some of it dating back more than half a century. When asked how his diocese is doing that, Plouffe said softly: "The best way we can." When you're involved in the legal process, you try to be as sensitive as you can to the issue "because it hurts. It hurts people." That legal process can sometimes be restrictive, said the bishop. "You can't do at times what you would like to do." In the best of all possible worlds, Plouffe said he would be able to sit with the accusers and the accused - "and see what we can do to help these people in a very practical way without having to go through a process which is, at times, very painful." Plouffe said the goal would be to "alleviate the hurt as much as you can, be as fair and honest as you can, so that people can move on." Someone finding it very difficult to move on is Daniel Contant, 54, of Callander. Contant sat in the audience at Monday's news conference as his sister, Anita Contant, 60, spoke about the abuse she suffered as a child. Anita Contant is one of the seven plaintiffs in new lawsuits being handled by Ledroit Beckett. She alleges she was abused by Father Magnus J. Fedy and Father Victor Killoran, both of whom taught at Scollard Hall in North Bay and both of whom are dead. Killoran pleaded guilty in 1990 to sexually abusing a boy and girl in Kitchener-Waterloo. Daniel is one of three plaintiffs who launched lawsuits last year against the Diocese of Sault Ste. Marie for sexual abuse by Fedy and Father John Fisher. He was too overcome with emotion at Monday's news conference to speak to reporters. On Tuesday, Daniel Contant said priests who sexually abuse children commit "soul murder." He said his alleged abusers "systematically brainwashed and seduced you in a way that you felt that you were doing right in the eyes of God. "We were taught that priests in general were all representatives of God in conjunction with our Roman Catholic upbringing from the day that we were baptized into this faith," said Daniel. "How much is a life worth when all you have left is an empty shell to attempt to grow and nurture yourself with, aside from all the psychological effects that comes along with being victimized? Daniel said he is grateful to other alleged victims who have come forward because it encourages his resolve and empowers others to go public with claims of abuse. Contact: cmulligan@thesudburystar.com The Cases Here, are some of the facts in seven lawsuits launched recently against the Roman Catholic Church in Ontario. None of the allegations have been proven in court: Anita Contant v. The Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation of the Diocese of Sault Ste. Marie and the Congregation of the Resurrection in Ontario. Perpetrators: Father Magnus J. Fedy and Father Victor Killoran, both deceased. Abuse alleged to have occurred at Scollard Hall; Raymond Carriere v. The Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation of the Diocese of Sault Ste. Marie. Perpetrator: Father Rene Hebert, deceased. Abuse alleged to have occurred at L'Annonciation Church in New Sudbury; J.G. (name not given) v. Gerald Roy and The Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation of the Diocese of Sault Ste. Marie. Perpetrator: Father Gerald Roy (living). Abuse alleged at Notre-Dame-des-Victoires Parish in Field; Thomas Miller v. The Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation of the Diocese of Sault Ste. Marie and the Congregation of the Resurrection in Ontario. Perpetrator: Father Victor Killoran. Abuse alleged at Scollard Hall; Gregory O'Connor v. The Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation of the Diocese of Sault Ste. Marie and the Congregation of the Resurrection in Ontario. Perpetrator Father Magnus J. Fedy. Abuse alleged at Scollard Hall; R.D. Sabourin v. The Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation of the Diocese of Sault Ste. Marie. Perpetrator: Father Rene Hebert. Abuse alleged at L'Annonciation Church; Notice Letter of Kevin Bishop to the Province of Ontario and The Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation of the Diocese of Sault Ste. Marie. Perpetrator: Father John Fisher. Abuse alleged at Vita Way Farms in Powassan, Ont.
Any original material on these pages is copyright © BishopAccountability.org 2004. Reproduce freely with attribution.