Price for Priestly Sins of the Flesh, by Rob Woollard, The Standard, July 17, 2007

Price for Priestly Sins of the Flesh

By Rob Woollard
The Standard
July 17, 2007

http://www.thestandard.com.hk/news_detail.asp?pp_cat=20&art_id=49119&sid=14502765&con_type=1

Attorneys for the Roman Catholic Church in Los Angeles and hundreds of people sexually abused by priests were due to appear in court in the city yesterday to file a US$660-million (HK$5.14 billion) settlement, the biggest in US history.

Lawyers for the Los Angeles archdiocese and 508 victims of abuse dating back to the 1940s thrashed out the massive deal on the eve of a potentially explosive court case. However, it must be approved by a Los Angeles Superior Court judge.

The deal is the largest settlement by any Roman Catholic archdiocese to sex abuse victims in the United States.

Archdiocese head Cardinal Roger Mahony - who has been accused by angry victims of attempting to cover up pedophilia cases during his tenure - told a press conference on Sunday that the cases should never have happened.

"This long journey has now come to an end, and a new chapter of that journey is beginning," Mahony said.

"Once again I apologize to anyone who has been offended, who's been abused by priests, by deacons, by religious men and women or by lay people. It should not have happened and should not ever happen again."

Mahony said he was haunted by the fact that victims would never be able to reclaim their innocence.

"It is the one part of the settlement process I find so frustrating, because the one thing I wish I could give the victims, I cannot," he said.

Ray Boucher, the lead attorney for the victims, said the settlement was long overdue.

"Some of the victims have waited more than five decades for a chance at reconciliation and resolution," Boucher said. "This is a down payment on that debt long overdue."

Abuse cases across the country have cost Roman Catholic churches around US$2.1 billion to date. Several priests have been convicted and at least four dioceses have gone bankrupt paying civil penalties.

The Los Angeles church is expected to sell off assets from its estimated US$4 billion real estate holdings to pay for the settlement.

The church had already settled 46 cases in December for US$60 million.

John Manly, a lawyer who represented around 50 victims who now stand to receive payouts of US$1.2 million-US$1.3 million each, said the archdiocese had settled to avoid the embarrassment of a court case.

Manly said the release of internal documents as part of the settlement would raise questions over the leadership of Mahony.

"I think when people see the documents and see what he knew and what he did they will be stunned," Manly said.

Victims accuse Mahony of allegedly covering up evidence of child molestation by transferring priests to other churches and for trying to keep the abuse reports secret.

"Cardinal Mahony paying out money is great, but where is the accountability from the hierarchy of the church?" Manly said. "They will continue their lives as normal; the victims still have to deal with a lifetime of problems."

Manly questioned why Mahony had not been held to account. "If what transpired under his leadership was bad enough to pay a half billion dollars, why is he still walking free, and why hasn't the district attorney taken action against him?"