MASSACHUSETTS
Daily Herald
Robin Washington
When Paul Shanley was escorted out of the Cambridge, Mass., courtroom after his Feb. 15 sentencing for the serial rapes of a Sunday school student in the 1980s, he was marching toward his death.
Not that there's capital punishment in Massachusetts, but the 12- to 15-year sentence the 74-year-old defrocked priest gets will be de-facto equal to life.
If he's lucky. I have zero faith in the corrections system that allowed the prison murder of fellow molester ex-priest John Geoghan keeping the even more notorious Shanley alive.
And who'd miss him? After the verdict, untold others prevented by statute of limitations from ever telling a courtroom their tales of abuse at the hands of the charismatic priest shed tears of relief. For three years I have been indelibly touched by their horrific stories and can only grasp at a hint of their pain. But if Shanley's conviction is viewed by them as a victory, it's a hollow one.
Our legal system hinges on reasonable doubt, and it abounds in this case. Rather than in the courtroom, Shanley's real trial was held in a hotel ballroom three years earlier, where a lawyer playing judge, jury and executioner wowed a throng of journalists and live TV audience with a PowerPoint presentation of voluminous church files to deem the priest as the devil incarnate.
Posted by kshaw at March 10, 2005 04:15 AM